Reading Room 9/4
Article: https://www.uncw.edu/jet/articles/Vol16_2/editor.pdf
The article introduces the idea of using game theory in the classroom (from the movie/book A Beautiful Mind).
Game theory encompasses cooperative learning in a way that is intended to motivate students’ active involvement in the learning process so that they have the maximum amount of payoff. There is an interesting divide between two student types. The first being students who seem active and confident that they can work together as a team, combine their knowledge, and use one another as resources in order to come to a unanimous agreement as to what the chosen answer will be for an assignment or quiz. The other students are those who would either not run the risk of working in a group, feel uncomfortable working in a group, and would rather work alone.
The reasons a students may feel uncomfortable joining a group and collaborating could be extensive. Perhaps they do not want their ideas to be discounted, that they will be a small voice lost in a crowd, overlooked, and that a more assertive student will continue to advocate that their answer is right, refusing to hear otherwise. Furthermore – when considering game theory – the payoff for individual students may seem too high a risk, and therefore working on their own is a safer bet in their mind. While a study was done in the article that shows the success of groups and how the individuals were less successful, except in the case of a single student. I wonder then if unprepared students work alone because they know they have minimal resource to contribute, or that they are highly prepared and do not want to have their peers relying on them for answers. That would lead me to wonder what motivation and level of preparation students in groups have. Are they highly prepared and willing to help others? Are they partially prepared and know they have enough to minimally fit in? Do t hey have no preparation and expect to be lumped in for the good grade?
I think an excellent way to develop this theory would be to survey students as to why they either like or dislike collaboration and what the benefits or deficits of collaborative work are? I think understanding their minds and why they make the decision to either work in groups or alone could help to structure preparation toward collaborative work in a positive way. For instance, if there were four assignments in which the class would be tested on, and groups could be formed beforehand so that each student was responsible for a singular article, would they be more inclined to work in groups? Considering that scenario, however, would the students only be learning 1/4 of the materials that they would be learning otherwise? Can similar standards be taught different ways in different articles so they are all reading different articles but answering questions based on the same content type? I think collaborative work, namely the game theory that stems from it, has potential to encourage students to work with one another. Integrating game theory into collaborative work could cause the retention of information to be high, for they have an expectation placed on them (depending on how minimal or non-minimal the role is), or it could alienate students who assess the risk of working with others to be too high to begin with.
Coming out of this article, I would be interested in seeing surveys of why students either like or dislike collaboration, what the pros and cons are in their eyes, and, for those who prefer to work alone, what could be done to get them to participate? Collaboration seems an important tool for learning so I wonder why there are individuals who opt to work alone?