Reading Room 9/11

Article (Journal of Effective Teaching): https://www.uncw.edu/jet/articles/Vol16_2/Kostouros.pdf

This article initially weighs whether using trigger warnings in post-secondary education are necessary when showing depictions of the suffering of others. The author eventually evolves from this idea to wonder how a teacher would use these materials in a way that strikes a balance between not enough and too far.

While the author starts by posing an important consideration – are trigger warnings necessary prior to engaging in materials that depict the suffering of others – they ultimately develop the conversation into a consideration of the pedagogical practice of teachers when presenting such materials. The depictions of suffering are invited to be a pedagogical tool in order to evoke a new way of thinking or acting within the world or are used as a ‘call to action’ to engage in a life beyond the student’s own life. By elevating the conversation, the author provides questions for teachers to consider and reminds them of a responsibility to the students and their learning.

I find myself more fixated on the latter content rather than the earlier, but I understand the connection between being considerate and intentional with the materials that a teacher chooses to have students engage with. While the author states that they are interested in how teachers can use the materials well, I wonder what makes materials necessary to witness and why? Are there depictions of suffering that are not important to view for the development of a student’s knowledge and empathetic capabilities? Is empathy a possibility, or is it that the precariousness of life is too overwhelming for the student?

A lot of what is being discussed reminds me of Megan Boler’s The Risks of Empathy: Interrogating Multiculturalism’s Gaze, in which Boler states that “rather than seeing reading as isolated acts of individual response to distant others, testimonial reading emphasizes a collective educational responsibility” (Boler 163). What is at stake in both texts is self reflection, foremost. The student is to use these images of  suffering not to shrink away in horror but to witness their own suffering and differences from those who suffer. This can lead to an elevated perspective when it comes to a student questioning why history, social structures, or institutions allow for the suffering of another. So begins the process of engaging in the diverse life that exists beyond them in different frames (that of culture, history, time, etc.). I also like Boler’s idea of testimonial reading as being a type of reading that “recognizes its own limits, obstacles, ignorances, and zones of numbness, and in so doing offers an ally to truth’s representational crisis” (Boler 169). This establishes a boundary for respect when reading, rather than distance. I think this type of reading is important in relation to empathy, for I do not feel as though empathy can be experienced. I will not always know the loss of another, but by recognizing the limits of my experience in which I read with can I understand your loss more fully.

The self reflection I mentioned earlier, however, can manifest in a way that would be considered “too far”, by causing secondary trauma that impedes the learning of a student for they are too overwhelmed to find meaning in the materials. The author talks about how they have a counselling background, and how teachers may not be able to recognize these shifts in disposition or may not actively be looking for them. This seems to me the most problematic part of using depictions of suffering: teachers who do not have their capacity to detect changes in students or are not cognizant that this may be a problem. I am wondering if there are any opportunities for instructors, no matter what level they are at, to develop their pedagogical practice so that they can do their best to present materials in a way that does not result in this? Is it possible to avoid secondary trauma and suffering? Will a teacher always know if they have successfully navigated a semester or a class in which this was not experienced?

My takeaway from the article is that there is a need to not only develop skills in students to be active readers who participate in self-reflection, the questioning of social constructs/history/institutions, but as having a necessity to engage in the lives (past or present) around them for we live in a shared world. I also see the responsibility a teacher has to understand – to their best ability – the needs of the classroom community in which they engage with, their needs, and how to balance material so that students are engaging in a way that is not too little and not overwhelming. The question is how to strike such a balance, and I think that is something that evolves, changes, and depends on the student(s) that teacher(s) work with. As there is a fluctuation of needs in the classroom, teachers must understand that they come to the classroom with the responsibility to not only have the students witness but witness in a way that does not impede their learning or cause secondhand trauma. This article presents a nest of intricacies in which responsibility is the teachers but also the students.

Megan Boler’s article I retrieved through OneSearch.

Previous Article
Next Article