An Argument for YA Literature in the First-Year Composition Classroom

I chose to read the article “The Young Archive and First-Year Writing: Using School Stories to Encourage Students’ Scholarly Identity,” by David Aitchison because I gravitate toward any research pertaining to First-Year Composition, as I am currently teaching an English 114 course as a GTA this semester.

Aitchinson examines the struggle often faced by teachers and administrators of First Year Composition classrooms calling them “the most misunderstood places on campus.” He states the freshman English level is backed by 30 years of research on student retention and skill development, and that this level has the responsibility of preparing students for the rigors of college-level reading and writing (302). However, he argues that Administrators, teachers, and college students have often held this course in contempt due to the varying approaches in teaching, and students often find the material  boring and lacking purpose.

When Aitchinson discusses First-Year students, he refers to traditional-age students who enroll immediately after high school. He suggests a way to get freshman students engaged in First-Year English is through the use of “The Young Archive,” which refers to the use of Young Adult Literature, and other media that thematically speaks to coming of age, or adulthood. The core of his argument for the use of “The Young Archive” is that students will be able to directly see themselves in the literature in the emerging “foundational themes.” If the teachers search the archive more in-depth, they may find material that discusses young people and their journey to literacy. The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian by Sherman Alexie is used as a model text to engage readers, and get them to explore their own reading and writing identities.

Aitchinson addresses the skepticism that Y.A. Literature may be considered too easy for college-level readers. He suggests that the true value is found in the content. He believes not only is it important for students to see themselves through these titles, but they can learn what it means to struggle as a learner, another theme found in these titles. Aitchinson adds that some Y.A. literature can even speak to adult themes when closely analyzed.

Aitchinson offers a solid argument for including YA literature in the classroom. Even if a First-Year composition teacher does not choose to use The Young Archive in their course, there are many important takeaways from this article: Literature should be purposeful; Aitchinson refers to canonical texts that seem far removed from young student lives, and are not shown why they are important to students. If the important metanarratives that young students bring with them to the classroom are not addressed with YA literature, they should still be explored to build students’ emerging identities. And lastly, that all writing should always start with informal quickwrites–these personal responses allow students to voice their opinions, which lay the groundwork for more analytical work.

My takeaway from this article is to consider YA literature when planning my course. As a English Education undergrad, YA lit. was recommended material for high school students. However, I have never heard it recommended for post-secondary English levels. This year I started my course with a “writing reflection” unit, and I do include authors like Amy Tan, Sherman Alexie, Frederick Douglass, and Malcolm X so that students can see how other thinkers gained literacy. The students then wrap the unit with writing their own “writing project” narrative, that reflects on any experience they find to be important.

I will look into YA lit to see if it can be helpful to my students because to me,  ideal texts are texts that students can engage with, see themselves in, and can serve a higher purpose to their reading and writing lives. And The Young Archive may do just that.

Previous Article
Next Article