How to do Grading With Words: Weekly Writing Assignments and Descriptive Rubrics

I enjoy the article called “How to do Grading With Words: Weekly Writing Assignments and Descriptive Rubrics” as the author humorously tells a story of her crisis with grading 90 one-page paper assignment every week. Her initial plan was to have each paper worth 2% for her ten-week semester, making the full portfolio worth 20%. She believes in weekly, short, low-stakes writing assignments as one of the best ways to help students improve their writing skills and build their confidence over the course of the semester. From a student’s perspective, I do not always find it exciting to write a paper every week, but I know that consistent practice is the key to improving any skill. As I was reading the article, I could feel how overwhelmed the professor must have felt to receive 90 papers every week and to be expected to return grading and feedback by the following week. She confessed that she found it too stressful to follow her usual way of grading, which required her to deduct points for each error (i.g. 1.5 out of 2%). This approach to grading seems daunting; it sounds not only mechanical and rigid but also exhausting to come up with justification for every evaluation she makes. This mechanical way of grading for teachers is time and energy consuming (she could be using this energy and time elsewhere to improve her teaching material or help students) and could potentially suck the joy out of teaching. This stress over the nitty-gritty of grading 90 different papers prevented her from grading any papers at all up until mid-semester, which caused students to be “in near revolt.” She confided in her colleague about her crisis and learned that the colleague used a non-numeric, descriptive rubric. Hence, the professor discarded her old grading system based on points and replace it with descriptive-words-grading. Instead, she came up with the following categories: EAG (Exceptional Awesome Glowing), GWWP (Good Work Well-Played), GTNW (Getting There Needs Work), NSWKG (Needs Significant Work Keep Going), and WIT (Where Is It?). I laughed when I read “Exceptional Awesome Glowing” because it does not fit the culture of academia that usually emphasizes rigorousness and has an overall tone of seriousness. I appreciate her word choice because it shies away from a punishing mechanism and stigmatization, and instead lightens up the grading process, which could possibly lessen the anxiety of students. I also appreciate the effort she put into developing descriptive words that are devoid of ableist or classist language to students’ writing, both of which appear in academia quite often. Ableist language involves words like strong and weak, and classist language consists of words such as rich, elegant, and poor. Furthermore, I noticed that each description, except for “Exceptional Awesome Glowing”, includes the word, “work.” I believe this helps students to focus on the quality of their work instead of taking feedback personally and thinking that their paper reflects their innate qualities. I am curious as to how her students responded to this new way of grading, and how it affected (or did not affect) their motivation and attitude towards a writing assignment.

The article includes her colorful rubric that she shares with her students to keep track of their progress. Aside from making the grading process cheerful and light, I think her chart could be useful to find out which week students struggle. The professor can then use that piece of information to ask students what they did not understand and review particular concepts as a way to help them improve their writing.      

 

From HASTAC

https://www.hastac.org/blogs/tlcowan/2018/08/27/how-do-grading-words-weekly-writing-assignments-and-descriptive-rubrics

Previous Article
Next Article