Building a Canon for the Teaching of Literature

In his article, “The State of Scholarship on Teaching Literature,” Paul T. Corrigan reports on and contemplates the broader community of scholars who write or have written on teaching literature and the disparity, potential, and necessity for greater continuity and conversation across the discipline.

Paul Corrigan (photo taken by Christine Corrigan, 2015) https://paultcorrigan.com/

Compared to the abundance of pedagogical scholarship on writing, Corrigan rather convincingly argues that literature pedagogy currently appears thin at best.  Corrigan grounds his argument in a study he conducted using citations.

Corrigan selected five of what he considered the most prominent journals on teaching English and examined all the articles on teaching literature in the publications’ issues across a decade, from 2005 to 2015.

“I determined which articles to include by reading titles and, when titles were insufficient, reading or skimming key terms, abstracts, introductions, headings, conclusions, body paragraphs, and so forth,” writes Corrigan.  “I then collected and compiled from these articles all of the bibliographies (i.e., works cited or references) into a single metabibliography.”

In total, Corrigan compiled 5,215 bibliographic references.  More than anything, what his study highlights is the lack of intracitation amongst all these references: in what amounted to 251 articles, there was very little reference throughout them to other scholarship on literature pedagogy.

However, just based on his metabibliography, Corrigan claims there is great potential to build a meaningful intertextual dialogue around the teaching of literature.

“Without citations, we are all just sitting in our own rooms talking to ourselves, he writes. “Citations do not just point to larger conversations—they create them.”

While a great deal of the scholarship on teaching literature appears to be not connected through citation, Corrigan notes that the four most cited authors–Graff, Scholes, Rosenblatt, and Booth–are literature pedagogy scholars.  Thus, a conversation has begun but has not yet fully developed nor has it been brought into a broader, more foundational community than the niche zone of the top journals in this field.

Corrigan suggests one way to improve upon this disparity is by bringing literature pedagogy more into graduate programs and colleges in general. “The scholarship on teaching literature would greatly benefit from the development of literary scholars for whom the study of teaching is not accidental or arrived at later in their careers but integral from the beginning,” he writes.

He also suggests various public endeavors from establishing an association to holding conferences and publishing journals. “But finally […],” he writes, “I simply recommend that literary scholars writing about teaching literature do more to read and cite other works on teaching literature. We do not need comprehensive literature reviews for everything we write. We need only converse with one another more deeply than this analysis of citations suggests we presently do.”

 

Previous Article
Next Article