Response to Diana Cardenas and Susan Loudermilk Garza’s “Restructuring Student and Teacher Roles: Dealing with Struggle”

In their essay, Cardenas and Loudermilk, who are both technical writing teachers, discuss the resistance and hesitance that students experience when it comes to a change in classroom structure in which the students become “active shapers” instead of “recipients of information”.  In order to do this they gathered as much information as possible by reflecting on how they taught in the past, studying articles and essays about teaching technical writing, and discovering what the community needs from technical writers. With this information they created the following model:

 First, we decided that we want students to write texts that effectively engage a particular audience that is affected by the writing. Second,  we  want  our  students  to  search  for  the  content  of  texts  within  community  settings  that  are  important  to  them  and  then  collaborate  with  others  to  effect  creation/development  and  revision for the texts they produce. Third, we create our curricular designs to assure that students determine  what  valuable  writing  is  for  them.  Fourth,  we  stress  that  knowledge  includes  having  students experiment, encounter challenges and setbacks, and re-think and evaluate their approach to  learning  in  order  to  make  choices  that  effect  solutions.  These  four  components  have  to  align  with each of the others in order to construct an effective model for the classroom.

In their approach, they made students create three portfolios. The first portfolio contains a series of documents that they have to write after meeting a technical writer at a workplace they see themselves working at in the future. There they interview the writer, ask what is required of them in their position, and ask for sample documents. The student must study the data they’ve collected regarding what they’ve learned, study the sample document, and try to write one themselves. The second portfolio contains resumes and cover letters, job reviews, and a memo describing the process of how they developed this portfolio. The third portfolio is all about what the community needs where they need to address a problem in their community that needs solving, conduct thorough research of this problem, and then think of possible solution(s).  Through these three portfolios and the actual effort that the students need to exercise themselves, the students are really able to personalize the course into something that they are interested while also being able to gain practical knowledge of their subject. They also allow students to create their own time frames, decide which software programs and websites they would like to use to help them in their process, and they are able to evaluate themselves in regards to the needs of the community.

However, there was resistance from the students since it was not close to the normal classroom format that they are used to. Some students discussed their feelings of frustration and confusion and felt that the teachers were not playing an active role in their learning and were not clear on what they expected from the students. The way that these teachers addressed this was by taking time in class to explain their model and methods in teaching this class and to be clear in what they expect from themselves as teachers and from the students. They also conduct surveys that ask students what is working and not working in the course, and also ask students to discuss their frustrations as they’re explaining them. They also made use of classroom readers, where there were 5 students per class who the students could speak to or ask for assistance from.

I think the model that they created is not only important but also incredibly practical. The students are actually learning about their field and what’s expected of them not only as students in the class but as future professional technical writers. In our own class, we’ve been learning about how important it is for teachers to step back and give the students a more prominent role, and it’s not something that I feel I’ve done in the past. For me, that has always been done via discussion, debates, and projects in my class. But it never exceeded that. So in our discussions, I’ve kept on thinking of how I can do that in my classrooms in the future. And although I understand that these are college students studying technical writing that they are dealing with and that I still have a long way to go when it comes to figuring out different ways to make the students more active, this model that they’ve created is really interesting and shows me how it is something that can be done, and successfully at that.

Previous Article
Next Article