Reading Room 10/10
Using Digital Rhetoric in a Multimodal Assignment to Disrupt Traditional Academic Writing: Conventions in a First-Year Writing Classroom
From: Journal of Interactive Technology and Pedagogy
The article discusses First-Year students’ apprehension toward writing a traditional essay that is targeted at an academic audience. Furthermore, it introduces the anxiety that many FYSs (first-year student/s) feel due to a lack of preparedness in high school and not knowing how to “invoke” an audience (imagine and construct the audience). This is problematic, according to Melanie Gagich, because it has students operating within the binaries of “good” and “bad” (no creativity), and how well a student is able to imitate the traditional academic essay (a “current-traditional rhetoric” practice).
First and foremost, this immediately reminded me of our class discussion of Ersatz Learning, for the students are “imitating” instead of authentically and holistically understanding the underlying concepts and practices/processes they are implementing. This is a connection I saw with the text, and Gagich goes on to supplement this problem, this Ersatz type of learning by using digital rhetoric as as a framework for multimodal composition practices. They argue that it is a “rigorous academic endeavor” (intro ¶) that helps students to better imagine or “invoke” an audience and still achieve the desired rhetorical type of writing that exists outside of the traditional. The author identifies an assignment they consider problematic, establish why that is, and then revises it so that it does not conform to the CTR (current-traditional rhetoric) writing style as well as does not place writing in a set of binaries (“good”/”bad”).
The article promotes giving students alternatives in relation to the traditional academic essay that allows for creativity, choice, and helps to focus audience. Furthermore, it does not apply the pressures of “good” (“what a good essay looks like/should do”) and “bad” (“what a bad essay looks like/does”) writing. It focuses the student on the task of writing and that process. Additionally, the author uses the writing to promote being multimodal in that the audience is real and interactive as opposed to imagined and abstract. It places the student in the writing community and acknowledges them as a writer. The author uses a plethora of questions in order to guide the students to specific considerations (reminds me of Professor’s “bound but open” idea).
Implementing this I would imagine to be beneficial to FYSs, especially those concerned with writing. The transition between high school and college is challenging, especially when considering the added pressures and expectations a student might feel. Furthermore, it is important to encourage student retention and connections between students, their professors and other peers to retain them as students. Beyond the role of students, it is important to encourage the success of these individuals for teachers are in place to serve students, and by fostering an environment where everyone is supporting one another not only as students and writers but as individuals is important.
This article resonated with me for it puts student learning first. It embraces not only a learning that exists beyond Ersatz but additionally seems to be operating in backward design. The author of the article recognizes a need for revising the desired results for improved student learning, and restructures an entire assignment to tailor to that. What I get from the article is that the student – naturally – comes first and foremost, and to consider constructing or building off of prior assignments in order to better achieve heightened learning. Keeping in mind that they are FYSs, it is also important to consider their needs coming into the institution, creating a connection within the community and on an individual level, as well as allowing them to achieve the desired goals but in a way that does not limit or define their writing before it has begun (“good”/”bad”). The author also acknowledges that “invoking” audience is difficult for almost any writer, and by attempting to make the audience a more tangible thing for the students is admirable. This shows to me that although an assignment might be deemed a failure, by restructuring, reconsidering, and revising it, it may be salvageable or respond well to new innovative tactics. So, instead of throwing it in the trash, reconsider the ways in which it operates, and also consider the multimodal, digital rhetoric in planning assignments.