Reading Room 6: Making Disability Part of the Conversation
The last few articles I have responded to focused on and encouraged the use of technology as a pedagogical tool in the classroom. While these methods of teaching were highly effective, the educators who had shared these methods failed to remark on its accessibility to all students. In the article, “Making Disability Part of the Conversation: Combatting Inaccessible Spaces and Logics”, Rick Godden and Anne-Marie Womack address the positives and negatives these methods offer when it comes to working with students who have disabilities.
One of the first topics mentioned within this article was the decline in technology being used pedagogically. Some educators argue that old fashioned note taking is superior to modern technology and have therefore banned the use of laptops within the classroom. “‘Associate Professor Carol E. Holstead reports, “I told students they would have to take notes on paper. Period.”’ This trend, however, is what I consider to be extremely problematic. Studies show time and time again that not everyone has the same learning experience. The argument for banning laptops in the classroom is always the same: student distraction and their inability to focus on the lesson being taught. But what about the students who need assistive technology? Though educators are required to accommodate students with disabilities, the banning of laptops is still a form of discrimination. Godden and Womack make a good point: “Can any pedagogy be sound if it doesn’t fully incorporate people with disabilities?”
It is difficult to create a curriculum that caters to all students’ individual needs. Even with the option to choose, one student may benefit from screen time while another might be distracted by their peers’ screen. In addition to this, a student’s accommodation request can essentially out them as having a disability. Godden and Womack mentions a study that analyzed students’ perception of people with disabilities. The study found that “granting an accommodation was seen as less fair than not granting one.” Due to the stigma, many students do not communicate with their professors about having a disability. This creates another problem in trying to form a curriculum that adheres to a diverse student population.
So what is the answer to the aforementioned issue? Unfortunately, there really isn’t a defined way to fix the problem. As someone who struggles with having a disability, I find that communication is the only way to improve one’s consciousness of the issue. Educators should try to work on making disability a part of the conversation within a classroom setting. When creating a curriculum, we must acknowledge our possible biases. There is always room to grow.