Response to Kris Shaffer’s “Three Lines of Resistance: Ethics, Critical Pedagogy, and Teaching Underground”

In Shaffer’s article published on Hybrid Pedagogy, he discusses the resistance to apply theoretical changes we learn about through critical pedagogy to the academic institutions in the U.S. He argues that one thing that critical pedagogy does it show us how our current system is flawed, and that it is important to remove a defeatist approach to the question is change in academic institutions possible since doing so makes an ineffective, unethical, and wrong education the only option. He defines three lines of resistance: major institutional change in policies and practices,  gradual changes via day-to-day practices, and teaching underground. If critical pedagogues practice all three forms of resistance, then actual change can take place on both smaller and larger scales both of which are incredibly valuable.

Whereas in the previous Reading Room, I discussed the resistance that some of the students experienced in regards to a new academic model, this Reading Room is about both the resistance that some teachers when it comes to change and the actual resistance that teachers practice in order to create it. I have to admit, there are times in this class where I am quite defeatist. I think about everything we learn reading critical articles about education and pedagogy, and although I completely agree with what these pedagogues are arguing, I think that applying what I learned to my future classrooms will be impossible in the way that the institution is set up. But reading this is making me change my attitude because he states that large sweeping changes is definitely something we should aim towards, but that doesn’t mean small changes don’t matter or are ineffective. Shaffer’s three lines of resistance show how all three are important and can work together to create the institutional and localized changes that are ethical and actually have a positive effect on our students both now and in the long run.

Previous Article
Next Article