Reading Room- The Challenges and Opportunities of Urban Education
Duncan-Andrade and Morrell, veteran high school teachers and teacher educators, denounce the myth of equal opportunities and meritocracy and argue that urban schools (public) are designed to fail. Failure of some people is considered necessary in this society to classify them into the existing oppressive social structure in which some automatically gain access to power while others are denied.
They find it illogical to compare schools which receive adequate funding to those which do not and conclude that the latter (urban schools) is a failure. They critique this urban school reform rhetoric that perceives urban schools as failures; it does not recognize that urban schools are systematically designed to fail due to funding and structural inequalities. The authors point out the root cause of this failure mentality stems from an idea that someone has to fail in school to create populations that stay on the bottom of the hierarchy in order to justify the unequal distribution of power. Schools function as a critical site to sort out populations and naturalize the social hierarchy that teaches students to accept their positions. Thus they criticize the myth of meritocracy and equal opportunities that remain pervasive in the society which masks the fact that schools operate on an unfair system. When we are not critical of the fact that some people are designed to fail, we fail to understand the nature of the oppressive structure and to develop effective solutions to counter it.
Although having adequate funding is an important factor for urban school reform, money does not guarantee urban schools to become successful ones. In fact, the authors point out that increased material resources do not necessarily enhance urban high school student engagement or achievement. Rather, it is becoming more evident that there is no clear relationship between material resources and student outcomes. Given that material resources are not the ultimate solution to increase students engagement and outcome, the authors suggest that in order to reform urban schools into effective social institutions, it is critical to help schools and teachers build curricula and pedagogy that address the social conditions of a given community, support students to maintain their urban youth identities, foster a sense of agency in students, and encourage them to be active member of their communities to confront social issues. This process involves training and supporting school leaders and teachers in urban settings, and “ramping up efforts in all phases of the educational profession: recruiting, pre-service training, and in-service support and development” (9).
I found it convincing when the authors emphasize the importance of viewing school as a site to train students to become committed members of their own community. They are against the idea of using education as a way to escape poverty and find a better opportunity and lifestyle elsewhere. If educated students leave their community, poverty is likely to persist, and nothing changes. They say that the point of education is not to escape poverty but to end it. I like that these two authors, who are also veteran high school teachers, see students as active members of the community rather than docile beings. Even if students do not come into their classroom with a high level of engagement, they find ways to activate their agency and commitment. I would like to read further about their specific pedagogical strategies or approaches that they have developed over years to engage their students.