Response to Aria Chernick’s “The Phenomenology of Participation: Derrida and the Future of Pedagogy”
In Aria Chernick’s article published on Hybrid Pedagogy, she discusses how Jacques Derrida’s concepts of “ethical hospitality, freeplay, jouissance, and difference” have a major influence in her pedagogy since she believes it creates a very intimate and humanistic space for communal learning and knowledge production. In particular, she highlights the concept of hospitality and how it means that what is considered “the other” has the right to not be received with hostility in the classroom since it has a negative effect on the learning environment and “alters the rights and obligations of both students and teachers.” She states after understanding these concepts, she started to change her teaching practices and started to include more digital pedagogy because she believes it rejects power structures that give teachers power and not students, encourages knowledge making and not knowledge passing, and embraces differences as part of that process of creating knowledge. Whereas before she says her class was super limiting in terms of the medium of writing and research which created distance between what and how the students were learning and how they were creating their own knowledge, now the students are able to compose digital texts using blogs to study the role that social media plays in creating social and political change. She argues that “A liberatory pedagogical model based on hospitality not only redesigns the space of the classroom into a transformative learning environment but also mirrors the future of academic work as collective public critical production.”
Honestly, I had to read this article a few times to understand what she was getting at and that is mainly because I am unfamiliar with Derridean concepts. Also, the idea of hostility in the classroom is something I had difficulty understanding and that’s probably because when I think of the word hostility, it’s usually more severe than what I suppose she regards to be tensions between teacher and student and between student and material. However, when I did finally understand what she meant by hostility, I started to make sense of what she was arguing for, and I totally agree with her. That hostility is there and I do believe that it, too, has a negative effect on the production of knowledge in that it doesn’t really create room for that in the first place. Play and interaction with multiple people and with multiple modes and mediums are what allows for real knowledge production to take place. If we are forcing students to write papers using limited sources and formats, if we are forcing students to listen and take in the knowledge of what they’re reading and not asking them to be active in the process of making that meaning for and among themselves, then we really are just keeping the current academic system alive, a system that we know isn’t working!