Reading Room 8: A Classroom Romance

In the article, “A Classroom Romance”, Laura Witherington discusses the impact a student can have on an educator and the reasoning behind this connection. The article I chose this week was particularly fascinating- especially with its choice of language. The name of the title itself alludes to a completely different topic altogether. The introduction to the article produces some sort of shock value; it is eye catching. “I’m a professor, and I’m in love with a student. It’s not the first time, either. Before I moved into teaching at the university level, I taught junior high English. I loved a student there, too.” She is not referring to romantic love but rather, a love for encouraging student success and developing a personal relationship with them.

Witherington’s love for her students did not come easy. She describes her first encounter with teaching junior high- “These students didn’t like school. At all. They didn’t like to read. They certainly didn’t like to write. They thought good grades were nerdy, and they weren’t going to be nerdy.” As  someone who is pursuing a career in teaching, I find myself often having anxieties about this exact situation. I believe this is a concern for most teachers in training and I suppose for most teachers in general. What can I do to encourage my students to learn? How can I relate to them in a way that promotes their ability to learn? Witherington’s love for her students came from developing personal relationships with these students. She started listening to the music they enjoyed and even started to prefer their dialects over the grammatically correct curriculum she was hired to teach. She started to care about the students themselves at a personal level.

Freire states that, “Dialogue cannot exist, however, in the absence of a profound love for the world and for people…. Love is at the same time the foundation of a dialogue and dialogue itself.” Witherington sees this quote as the basis for the article’s main idea. When I first started reading this article, I initially thought the piece would be centered around favoritism within the classroom. I was surprised to learn that while Witherington seems to place a heavy emphasis on this particular type of love, she rejects the idea of having more love for the gifted or more impressionable students. I suppose this is because I do not particularly understand her method of loving students. The words Witherington has chosen to use in this article makes the idea feel slightly problematic. What if students don’t want to have a deeper, personal connection with their professor? At the end of the article, she explains how an educator should feel about a student’s lack of engagement: “Our responses are often the same to being dumped romantically: wine and ice cream and tears. And these should be our responses, when we care.” Perhaps I am unable to grasp this feeling because I am yet to mentor students and guide them through the process of learning. Once I have the opportunity to teach, I am sure my opinions on the matter will change for the better. 

Previous Article
Next Article