Reading room- critically compassionate intellectualism
Cammarota and Romero, veteran public school teachers, argue that Latino/a students along with other students of color experience the oppression of silencing in school. Educational content serves the culture of the dominant groups who have the power to shape educational institutions, while it ignores cultural capital and intellectual contributions of subordinate groups. Under this logic, those who are familiar with the dominant culture are accepted as knowledgeable for displaying proper mannerisms, codes and communication patterns. On the other hand, those from subordinate cultures are viewed as incapable of intellectual capacities and thus expected to fail in school. In order to subvert this systemic silencing, the authors offer critically compassionate intellectualism as an educational model. This educational model combines three pedagogical practices: critical pedagogy, authentic caring, and a social justice-oriented curriculum.
Informed by Freire, critical pedagogy enables both students and educators to become subjects of knowledge rather than treating students as depositories and teachers as authority of knowledge. Authentic caring emphasizes the reciprocity between students and teachers and the importance of emotional connections between the two. The social justice-oriented curriculum builds content that matters and is significant to students’ lives rather than teaching content that ignores their conditions. These three elements of pedagogy, as the authors argue, have to be implemented in the classroom simultaneously to help Latino/a students deflect institutional power that silences them.
In this critically compassionate intellectualism, students are encouraged to see themselves as knowledgeable subjects in order to break their internalized belief that academic success is unattainable for them. Through dialogues with teachers, students share their knowledge from their lived experience and reinvent it through critical analysis. Yet, meaningful dialogues could take place only if teachers and students establish a relationship based on emotional connections through “authentic caring” rather than aesthetic caring. Authentic caring takes place when teachers establish emotional connections with students and demonstrate a genuine interest in students’ wellbeing. Aesthetic caring is treating students like objects and only providing them academic skills; in other words, teachers care about a technical side of students’ experiences rather than their overall wellbeing. The authors, having been educators at public schools for decades, point out how aesthetic caring prevails in traditional pedagogy where school reputation based on student performance becomes more important than students’ wellbeing. This form of caring emphasizes the importance of school rather than students.
Their discussion on authentic caring reminds me of bell hooks’ engaged pedagogy where she argues the importance of seeing students as whole human beings. I think it’s far easier to get trapped into aesthetic caring because teachers are constantly under pressure to improve students’ performance on standardized tests. But what are we saying to students when we show them that we only care about their grades? I think the core message of aesthetic caring is that students’ values lie in their level of intelligence, which is toxic. First of all, human values should not lie on their intelligence. Secondly, the type of intelligence that is measured at school and on standardized tests are narrow and limited; the emphasis on performance creates a sense of inferiority in students who “fail” to demonstrate this specific kind of intelligence. Also, why would students care to learn from teachers who don’t really see them as a person and only care about their test scores? While aesthetic caring seems to require less investment in terms of time and energy, it ultimately leads to lowering students’ motivation, which consequently affects their performance. It also creates students’ sense of alienation in their school experience. Authentic care, on the other hand, requires that teachers see individual students as unique, treat them as such, and respond to their differing needs. Authentic caring is the basis of any meaningful human relationship, and this should apply to a relationship between a student and a tecaher as well.