Reflection on Annotation Comrades Assignment
When I revised my Annotation Comrade’s assignment from my first draft, I wanted to hone in the scope. Perhaps my original goal of having students understand the “intertextuality of poetry” seemed overzealous, daunting, and a stretch. So setting out with much more specific goals for my Comrade to digest: i.e. the poetic convention “irony” in Eliot’s “Love Song,” seemed much more manageable. If my Comrade picked up on “intertextuality,” that would be a bonus, or achieving a secondary goal.
It worked. My Comrade appreciated the specificity of the assignment. Being able to work with one convention helped, and it allowed her to focus her approach to the text. She indeed, was able to make her own “intertextual” connection to “Romeo and Juliet,” which was surprising, and to me, a sign of engagement.
I wanted the annotations to aid in comprehending the poem, but I did not want the annotations to be the assignment. That is why I decided to have the annotations culminate to a response of a question. The instructions asked for my Comrade to read the poem in stages: first, to jot down any immediate responses; Secondly, to note how the speaker feels at every stanza; and finally, according to the guidelines, to identify metaphors, similies, themes, and references. I included this last stage because I thought it was important to have my Comrade look up any references to better understand the poem, if Eliot included any (like in “The Waste Land”). In “Love Song,” Eliot starts the poem with Italian, he references Hamlet, and he connects to Michaelangelo. My Comrade said looking for similies felt awkward, and was hoping for a more organic approach to reading the poem. The “unique, personal approach” she was looking for was my vision for “stage 1 reading,” but could have been stated more clearly. Stage 1 annotations could include more Reader Response style annotations, questions, difficulty, etc. and I should have reflected that in the instructions.
My Comrade’s response to my assignment applauded me for my specificity and design. The only critique was that she wished for a more organic, unique, and personal approach to the reading so that she could better understand the poem as a reader. I understand that it was my error because she could have those responses, but my instructions were not clear. This enforces the point to always have a day or reading “step” dedicated to the student and personal reading–identifying struggle, puzzlement, questions, or Reader Response-type annotations. My Comrade’s response made me realize some students prefer that type of reading and annotation.
Overall, I believe I was successful in my design (and revision) for my Annotation Comrades assignment. My Comrade engaged with the poem, and she work through difficulty. She also provided an excellent response, much like how I envisioned. As a teacher I would have graded the annotations for engagement, but concentrated more on the response as the “evidence” for a thorough reading. And my Comrade provided evidence of a thorough, thoughtful, and engaged response. Please see below:
My prompt:
Please Respond to the following: How is this poem a “love song”? Use your annotations to explain your response.
My Comrade’s Response:
Nice work Jillyann!
T.S. Eliot’s poem, The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock, is a different type of love song. It is not the standard everlasting euphoric love poem. Instead he uses a stream of consciousness technique to lament what love is, could have been, what he may have missed, and his vulnerability surrounding this largeness of love.
Eliot’s character constantly reflects on aging, in particular, his aging. He envisions it as old and worn, “with a bald spot in the middle of my hair…my hair is growing thin!” He is concerned about who he has loved, as well as how he has loved.
The reader doesn’t know if he is speaking to someone directly, rather we get this indirect sense he is addressing grander themes of love: fear, regret, hate, and aging. Perhaps in his world view, one has better fortune in love when one is young. Certainly, this latter view of love as seen from a young lens, such as Romeo and Juliet, is the more common perspective. But this does not imply that those who are aging, or old, cannot fall in love. Eliot’s character is limited in his view because of his insecurities about aging and about himself, “do I dare…his arms and legs are thin…” The poem is riddled with references to aging. Eliot’s masterpiece was written in the early 1900, and he was a well educated man. Did his own world view contribute to a life well planned, that is to say a life that did not involve a lot of risk? Being in love involves emotional risk, vulnerability; one enters a plethora of unknowns. But the experience of loving is worth the myriad risks. However, this character wants us to see love in its entirety. And this includes the disillusionment, the fear, and the trepidation.