Reflection: Annotation Comrades Assignment

When creating the Annotation Comrades assignment, I feared that my instruction would alienate non-poets and perhaps over simplify the idea of metaphor. My main objective was to create an assignment that would be accessible for a diverse student body. As a grad student in Creative Writing, I am often encouraged to explore contemporary works over the “greats.” In most introduction classes, it is standard to study the bigger names with little to no focus on artists in the present day. While I do consider studying Ginsberg and Dickinson to be imperative in truly understanding the craft, I wanted to present something off beat. In creating this assignment, I considered changing my selected piece to adhere to these unspoken rules about learning poetry. Layli Long Soldier is an up and coming poet, but she is by no means a go-to artist. This was evident to me especially in terms of analytics. The piece I chose to cover, Ȟe Sápa, Five, is challenging; it is not easy to dissect. From my own annotations, I discovered a heavy use of metaphor and the possibility of a fruitful class discussion. This is to be expected in most poetry, however, Long Soldier’s use of the metaphor is not surface level. I selected a common element of craft, the metaphor, and wanted my comrade or students to expand their knowledge on its many uses. In addition to this, I asked my comrade to create their own piece centered around the metaphor. I felt that encouraging experimentation is the best way to understand how Layli Long Soldier executed this piece.

After reading my comrade’s annotations, I was very much relieved and excited to see that she did more than just follow the assignment. She truly took the time to understand the poem and even created more annotations than required. The piece she wrote was great! It was fun to read and showed a clear representation of the assignment’s main objective. After reading her feedback, I was surprised to learn that this was something completely out of her comfort zone. The piece, which she admits was not an easy read, required her full attention. Though I worried about the piece being a bit too challenging, she seemed to really enjoy taking the time to decipher the work. My comrade’s feedback leads me to believe that this assignment was a success. If I choose to use this assignment in the future, I will most likely have my students analyze a different poem. My comrade praised Ȟe Sápa, Five’s complexities but I’m not so sure that an introduction class will. I will most likely choose another piece of contemporary work- one that is more relatable, fluid, and easier to navigate.

Previous Article
Next Article