Faculty Social Networking Interactions: Using Social Domain Theory to Access Student Views
Patricia L. Nemetz in the Journal of Instructional Pedagogies makes a claim that “educators consider[ing] using social networking sites, like Facebook, for educational innovations should be aware of possible vulnerabilities associated with the blurring of social and professional boundaries” (abstract). Research on the use of social networking includes studies showing both the benefits and pitfalls that indicate that students use social networking sites to maintain or strengthen their offline social networks. In recent discussions of social network interactions between faculty and students, Nemetz argues that a controversial issue is whether faculty should have unrestricted access to a student’s social network platform. On the one hand, some scholars argue that one in eight college women report having been stalked by faculty or peers online, so the possibility that social networking might facilitate cyberstalking by miscreant faculty or fellow students is one concern (Kirkland, 2010).
From this perspective, the paper argues that having access to the personal social media accounts of students or faculty interacting with their peers can have “unintended consequences [which may] hinder student[s] beyond their intimate social circles (3). On the other hand, however, others argue that “past campus incidents include athletic suspensions or dismissals for inappropriate verbal and photographic postings” (Armour et al), academic suspensions for postings of inappropriate photographs of selves, other students, or dignitaries (Gruss, 2007; Iyengar, 2006), and loss of prospective jobs for posting a risqué online persona (Finder, 2006). According to this view, there has been a blurring of lines when it comes to how faculty interacts with students online, or how students are accessing and interpreting the content of what their peers are posting on social media. In summary, then, the issue is whether it is right to regulate or ban teachers from using online social platforms to teach pedagogy or as a way to interact with their students outside the classroom. Attempts to train future K-12 faculty about violations of safety and privacy was met with divergent views according to Nemetz, the faculty in training were finding it difficult to clarify what constitutes invasion of privacy online. One study used case studies to analyze how social domain theory can be a training device that constitutes legitimate teacher and student interactions on social networking sites. The question about what constitutes moral conduct has led to some K-12 districts to regulate and even ban student-faculty relationships on social networking platforms for educational purposes (Affleck, 2010; Bowean & Mack; 2010; Garrow, 2010; Kieffer, 2010).
My own view is that there should be official spaces for interaction in digital spaces between faculty and students. For example, there can be a separate page for personal interaction with friends and family and another for school interactions. The theoretical research on social domain theory is also very important because it argues that individuals have different forms of social interactions and these lead to “different forms of social knowledge” and it can be a moral issue that pertains to others “rights or welfare” whether to cheat or not in an exam, conventional issues which relate to “agreed upon universal issues” an example could be if a student should remain in a seat for the period of the class, and finally how personal issues should have “consequences only to the actor and thus [be] viewed beyond society i.e rights to the body, who to associate with, or “the choice for a student to wear a beard, long hair, shorts, and sandals to class” (3). The author also admits that sometimes there are domain overlaps especially in the application of moral, conventional and personal issues as it raises moral concerns as well as social conventions or personal choice, and when all three overlap, it is then referred to as a multifaceted issue (Nucci). Taken in this light, interaction between students and faculty for educational purposes is an insightful process, because it opens for discussion the subject of how to access several discursive spaces for faculty and student’s education to thrive beyond the confines of a classroom.