Response to Andrea Dupre’s “Failed Educational Reform in the New York City School System”

In Adrea Dupre’s essay, she argues how Michael Gloomberg (Ney York City’s Mayor) and Joel Klein (Gloomberg’s first chancellor) enforced reforms on schools that were had major negative effects on the personal and academic lives on the students and forced them to become “victims of the massive school closures” and “victims of a top-down management structure that distanced itself from and lost sight of the very subjects it was supposed to benefit.” She focuses this essay on the Mury Bergtraum High School which was prosperous before Gloomberg’s policies came into the picture. Now, fewer students are graduating and more teachers are looking for ways out of the school, whether it be by retiring or giving up on the profession in its entirety. She believes that “Bergtraum serves as a microcosm for the failures of an American educational reform movement whose strategy has been based on principles of reorganization and privatization rather than on cooperation and collaboration.” She also clearly states the reasons why this new system failed: “the breakdown of large schools into smaller units, which inadvertently created a large pool of displaced students; and the centralization of power into the hands of the mayor, his chancellor, and a small army of school principals who lost sight of the needs of the diverse cohort of students, teachers, and support personnel at the bottom of the new chain of command.”

This article was a heartbreaking one as it epitomizes how the policies on education do not actually represent or have the best interests of the students, teachers, or schools in mind. In her explanation of how the school’s history of principals played a major role in harming the school the school’s learning environment by trying to implement zero-tolerance models from charter schools, I am reminded of my experiences in my high school in Palestine which was a prison to me. When the school’s administration is so strict, students feel like breathing punishable, and of course, like the students at Bergtraum, my classmates and I rebelled. We felt that the school was not supporting us or representing us in any way, and I do not think that these are unwarranted opinions. However, I remember watching a TED presentation by Linda Cliatt-Wayman, a principal at once was a very low-performing school but is now growing and prospering. The title of her presentation is a question with an answer: “How to fix a broken school? Lead fearlessly, love hard.” Schools need principals who sincerely care for their students and do what they can to implement changes to improve learning experiences and environments. Instead of putting blame on teachers and forcing them to figure out solutions for themselves, she invited strong educators to train the teachers and give them advice on different ways in which they can create the proper environment for learning and overcome learning disparities in the classroom. And instead of being ridiculously strict on the students, the principal showed sincerity and demonstrated to the students that she truly cares about them and their learning. Now I know this article focusses mainly on policies that have such negative effects on schools, but I believe that the reason this is the case is that they care very little for the students and their lives. If they adopted approaches like Cliatt-Wayman, wouldn’t they be far more successful?

Previous Article
Next Article