September 10, 2018: Learning Through Conversation
Learning Through Conversation by Dabiel Ginsberg (journal: Hybrid Pedagogy)
This article begins with a quote by Martin Kutnowski (whom I looked up and determined to be a teacher of music):
“My teaching portfolio speaks of challenges and failures alongside successes, all woven into a narrative organically establishing who I am and why I do what I do.”
Daniel Ginsberg relays his experience as a teacher and researcher of linguistics and anthropology. He states that ” If education is what happens in classrooms, learning is a much older and more fundamental phenomenon…” He states that all of learning is in fact participatory and questions how we may present ideas of a discipline as ‘ “motionless, static, compartmentalized, and predictable… completely alien to [their] existential experience?” ‘
Using his vast research, Ginsberg attempted to create a course where the students would be full participants in sociolinguistics. The were to work together closely in groups and create their own research questions collaboratively, investigate and research, and then present their findings to their peers. This was a conversational approach to learning.
However, the feedback that he receives at the end of this endeavor from he students was largely unfavorable. Students did not think that course requirements were explained clearly, they felt he did not offer enough information and instead expected them to have a graduate level understanding of the material. One student states, “he thinks he’s leading the discussion but really just wants us to agree with him. After a while I stopped trying.” Ginsberg reflects that he directed his students to accept an environment of “uncertain and incomplete understanding” but then he did not allow them the space to do so, by frequently interrupting the classroom dialogue.
Another student asserts, “Worst class I’ve ever taken. I learned nothing this semester,” and Ginsberg reflects that the student had worked collaboratively, written amazing papers by channeling their individual curiosity into research questions, while also researching theories that were relevant, and collected and analyzed data all resulting in phenomenal papers. He states rhetorically to himself, “… now wait a minute. You learned nothing? I read all your final papers, and they were good.”
(Personally, I was astounded at what harsh critics these students were, … but felt educated by Ginsberg sharing this. I suppose we will have to become accustomed to hearing a lot of this. I think it’s rare anyone gives a good review about anyone, it’s just not “constructive”, I suppose.)
In writing this essay Ginsberg realizes that the same principle of learning a subject applies to learning how to be a better teacher. That no one can give you the answers, the answers will need to be discovered through the experience and conversation. Therefore, feedback from the students was essential regardless of how negative it was or ill-informed (they did not see his greater vision and implementation as the teacher and expert on the subject.)
What Ginsberg had desired to communicate to his students was a new philosophy about education and learning and that it wasn’t to be an exercise of simply fulfilling duties and requirements “but a process of becoming” and “a developing understanding that knowledge is a human creation, and that anybody can be the one to add to it.”
It was almost too much for the linguistic extraordinaire to accept that he had failed to communicate this to his students, however, he gave the feedback careful consideration and reflected upon that conversation, about how he taught a class about conversation. The students were empowered and mastered skills, but Ginsberg realized he had failed to explain during the process how this was happening. So the students did not realize it had happened and they may not know how to use the method for themselves.
The article ends with a poignant quote by Ginsberg :
“I’m through with trying to empower people by telling them what to do. I resolve instead to be a better listener.”