Reading Room 9/11
For Reading Room this week I chose the article: “The Pretense of Neutrality: Twitter, Digital Literacy, and First-Year Writing” by Trevor Hoag from the Journal, Hybrid Pedagogy. Hoag asks of his readers, “To what degree should one desire or practice neutrality [in the classroom]?” I contend that teaching is an inherently political act. And as a hyper-analytical graduate student who works hard to understand social and political conditions plaguing this country, I wonder what ‘neutral’ teaching methods look like.
Hoag says he wants to avoid being the liberal brainwasher that conservative folks tend to hate. But how does one “neutrally” model critical thinking and compassion in a class of conservative students without shutting them out? Luckily, students interact with virtual worlds (twitter, social media etc.) which engage them outside of the classroom on political topics. Hoag asks us: why not start with these familiar online platforms for community building and critical thinking?–it will help students think more deeply about issues beyond their lives, right? I have a positive response to these ideas, since the classroom environment alone may be too far removed to facilitate thoughtful or empathetic discussion. So Hoag introduces some technological tools to bridge the classroom/virtual gap.
Methods for meeting students in their worlds include “Controversy Mapping” where students trace both sides of one issue and maintain neutrality, recording their data online using sites like Storify. Later, students present these varying standpoints to the class without asserting an argument but rather reporting on the nuance of the issue. The experience should be informative rather than argumentative. But is it actually possible for students to remain neutral in this exercise? I think it’s worth a shot, as it teaches discipline and ethical contemplation. Students have to do some research on a viewpoint that they maybe have never considered. Exercising a 360 view of a topic allows students to become more fluid with both analysis and empathy. And the presentation aspect informs the rest of the class for further thought and discussion. It seems like a rich opportunity.
Exercises like this prompt students to locate biases within sources, too. But I see a danger with that as well; students should not merely equate standpoints just for the sake of nuetrality. The above mentioned exercise is just a first step for me. To further encourage critical thinking, I would advocate for fact-checking exercises which prompt students to investigate and analyse methods of news media. I would copy Hoag’s model wherein he prompts students to draw their conclusions via twitter, a comfortable community setting for them.
In conclusion, Hoag offers me some important virtual platforms for neutrality exercises such as: Voyant and Genius. I hope to incorporate these one day in a class.