Reading Room 9/18

Radical Teacher: Identity Matters: Teaching Transgender in the Women’s Classroom by Kate Drabinski

Kate Drabinski calls for the teaching of transgender studies as a practice rather than an extension of identity. Known as transgender phenomena, it is defined as “any practice or act that steps outside the boundaries of gender normativity as against an understanding of transgender as a contemporary practice of identity” (Drabinski 143). The phenomena is used to go beyond the physical body into understanding the social practices of gender and the socially constructed hierarchy that we are all bound to through our bodies, race, sex, gender, and ability. Drabinski emphasizes that socially constructed categories (gay, lesbian, transgender, etc.) are necessary to acknowledge because it works to oppress the individuals who inhabit it, but identity is not to be confused as one of these categories. Rather, they fit into a category because of the identity they retain but need to be aware of the practices that produce the identity, and that they may not necessarily be something that they feel belongs to them. Drabinski is advocating for the shift to understanding these practices and how they contribute to social, cultural, and political issues that are a part of women’s/gender studies rather than looking to the already constructed category in which identity falls under and does not question its intersectionality.

The article argues against the treatment of gender-variant individuals as special guests, particularly transpeople. Essentially, to treat someone in the position of being a special guest is to respond to their socially constructed identity and to enumerate differences in relation to sexual norms and to treat them as other. This reduces an individual to their biology, where the construct of gender is rooted in. The transgender phenomena rather looks at relationship between practices and identity and their relationship to issues that affect everyone (socially, politically, culturally). The article does not focus on specific people but rather the practice that of stepping outside the boundary of sexual normativity.

An exercise the teacher of the Women’s and Gender Studies class has students do is to write a critical essay about gendered objects, such as Dove and Axe deodorants. Additionally, she uses standpoint theory – that images and practices can mean different things to different people – in order to show that one thing that may be viewed as “manly” (i.e. a person ordering whiskey) or belonging to a specific gender can be viewed differently by another.

I think this article poses a challenge for teachers to consider gender, sexuality, and identity outside of their socially constructed categories. Furthermore, there are individuals who base their understanding of another in relation to how that person fits into the category, rather than considering how the categories dictate these individuals perform their identity. Identity is personal, and to limit it to the societal construct is to not continue questioning the ways in which society attempts to contain one within a clearly defined category. Transgender phenomena is a way to separate what someone may think as inherently natural to one’s gender or biology and to understand it as being something fluid. While my biological sex is female, that does not mean I will automatically perform in a feminine understanding of gender just because of the inherent biology. Additionally, my unique identity (sexually, socially, politically, culturally, etc.) is not limited to move between two societal norms but rather has a range of fluidity. If I wear slacks and a button up shirt to a wedding, when using standpoint theory, it can be seen as a variety of things. Maybe I just don’t like dresses, or perhaps it is an example of transgender phenomena because I am performing gender as a lesbian.

This class seems important to me because it reinforces that gender is more complex than the categories and stereotypes it exists within. Furthermore, depending on the position of someone, their understanding of how I perform gender may differ between individuals, further supplementing the transgender phenomena as existing beyond the biological or physical, and realizing that it is rooted in socially constructed categories or conceptions about my body in various relationships (socially, etc.). I think the article advocates for individuals who do not fit into the gender norms as well as looks to be inclusive of transpeople’s issues and how they intersect with not only common gender issues but women’s issues. By taking a practice-based approach instead of an approach of identity, one understands the performative aspect of gender and how society constructs it as well as seeks to categorize individuals on where they fit due to aforementioned performance(s). Utilizing the transgender phenomena, transgender issues and theorizing allows for a wider understanding of the  practices being employed on bodies due to transpeople’s intersectionality in relation to the issues. The author cautions against viewing transgender issues as merely a battle between free choice (do I wear the dress or slacks?), because that then it reaffirms gender as something natural in addition to the violence that certain “free choices” results in. Transpeople do not have the same meaning for choice that I as a non-transperson have.

I think from a larger pedagogical viewpoint, that this article tasks instructors to not only be more inclusive in ways of thinking and teaching but also that students will not always necessarily fit into a specific type of category when it comes to their performance. To use the ideas presented here more abstractly and fluidly, students will not always perform in dynamic or categorical ways. To use the transgender phenomena, they may perform in a variety of ways that differ from how they are viewed biologically. Meaning that students may perform outside the boundaries of what their student norms may seem. For example, a student who has performed poorly in one area and is expected to keep that norm of poor performance may excel in unexpected areas or in different ways. Their performance is not reflective of their biological lack of English, math, or science, but rather that students exist in a fluid range of capabilities that may be rooted in time, location, space, content, etc. I performed really poorly in high school, especially in Biology. I got a D or D-. When I went to summer school, I received over 100%, resulting in an A+. I did not lack the capacity to perform a particular way, but rather my performance was a result of an ever-changing practice. If we are to view students’ performance as fluid rather than something inherent to them, that is to give them a more human understanding of who they are. We do not know the circumstances of their lives socially, culturally, politically, etc., and that may cause variances in how they perform. I think this is what Drabinski is arguing: that practice can vary from identity and that it is a fluid notion.

Previous Article
Next Article