e-Portfolio Use in Postsecondary, Interdisciplinary Education
In the article “ePortfolios and Individualized, Interdisciplinary Learning: A Case Study,” I was immediately intrigued to uncover the findings of NYU’s Gallatin School of Individualized Study and their implementation of ePortfolios as the core learning tool for interdisciplinary study. Piloting the use of their first platform in 2009, Gallatin’s small program within NYU’s larger establishment, sought to find a digital platform that was much like facebook, where students can interact and share their individual projects (their culminating project is called “the colloquium,”) along with the learning goals of synthesized learning and reflection. There has since then been 3 “iterations” of the ePortfolio, with each iteration coming closer to finding the ideal platform for Gallatin’s program.
The idea to use ePortfolios originally stemmed from Gallatin students wanting to collaborate with each other to share their individual projects. The first iteration of ePortfolios included the us of Sakai OAE (Open Academic Environment). This program used widgets, tools that could be pulled into any page (2). The use of Sakai was used and tested by grad students. Although having attractive features, the social media type of energy took away from academic and pedagogical purposes; the program became too costly; and even grad students found themselves wanting a more simplified platform.
The second iteration of the ePortfolio implemented the use of Google Drive. This seemed like a better fit for Gallatin for it shifted the focus to the text-based materials. Students could showcase their materials and keep their work in their drives, which seemed to align more with “the colloquium.” Although Google Drive was an improvement from Sakai, there was a low adoption rate, with only 1.9% of students placing content into their drives. Overall it was difficult to extract metric information from this program, and the low adoption rate might have been due to no “appealing public-facing aspect” of the ePortfolio (5). Another hiccup in this program might be the fact that much of the energy was used marketing this program to faculty and students, rather than encouraging faculty to properly learn how to use the program and use it in their classroom to engage students.
The third iteration of ePortfolio adopted the use of WordPress. This program seemed to be a better fit for the Gallatin because it was no-cost, and with its use, students can create appealing public-facing websites (6) and allowed students to build their digital identities through customization. This shift to WordPress refocused the energy back to the learning goal of self-reflection. This simplified program proved to be user-friendly as students created their own templates. Another advantage is that students built websites that showcase their professional work to help network and build their academic careers.
The most interesting thing I found in this article is the amount of work that goes into having an institution adopt a learning platform. I did not know the amount of research, piloting, and testing out that goes on behind the scenes. Gallatin’s 3 iterations illustrates how difficult it is, and perhaps the importance, of finding tools and technology that aligns with your academic purposes and learning goals. It is a laborious process that takes years of trying to get it right. As a postsecondary instructor, their research can inform my choices. If I choose to adopt WordPress as an ePorfolio platform, I can be confident that its been tried and true (at least as we stand). Furthermore, this article highlights the importance of the user. Students will be vocal about their needs (wanting to collaborate), and their opinions in technology.