Reading Room 10/2

From Addiction to Connection: Questioning the Rhetoric of Drugs in Relation to Student Technology-Use

From: Journal of Interactive Technology and Pedagogy

In this article, the author – Trevor Hoag – discusses how referring to students/other individuals as addicts, it attributes them with something problematic. It attaches to them an identity where many problematic assumptions come into play. By understanding the relationship with technology differently and those who use it, it shifts the power dynamics so that a person is not rendered powerless by technology, but rather gaining something positive and using it in a positive way.

 

The article considers problems with calling users of technology addicts or having an addiction. As someone who uses technology regularly, it doesn’t seem to characterize someone who needs technology to be successful as an addict. Additionally, it allows for different gateways into learning, the ability to research, and to communicate with peers and professors easily. Outside of an academic realm, the fact that I have been removed from the entirety of all I know to a different geographical location and culture, I find technology really important. I am able to communicate with those that are dear to me, see pictures of them, and participate in their lives in an indirect way. It gives me a connection to home and helps with feeling alone in some far off place. I think to change the terminology is to change the nature of the relationship people have with technology.

It is an increasing force within our lives, becomes more integrated at every passing moment. Inserting credit card chips, having food from restaurants delivered by people, using apps to have people come to walk dogs, and touch screen soda dispensing fountains is all too bizarre for me to stomach. Perhaps I don’t need to use an iPad to order my food while dining at a restaurant, only to have someone I have not be introduced to as being my selected, singular server or an array of bussers deliver my food. Cupcake vending machines? Some of the technology now is perhaps secondary, but it is also useful. Self check-out lanes when I am buying 50 lbs of Halloween candy for personal consumption? Yes please. But to characterize someone as an addict of technology, especially students, is an over-exaggeration. I don’t want to go out to dinner and have someone texting the entire time, yet it isn’t fair to judge the circumstances and needs of a person’s life by their use of technology. Everyone rightfully has their own relationship with it, and someone may utilize it more than others. But, within a classroom setting, it can be a distraction, or a pathway to learning.

Putting aside “the time when we grew up” and focusing on the needs and conditions in which individuals are entering the classroom today in relation to technology is pivotal. I was a student observer at a middle school and watched kids browse websites or play games that were irrelevant to the task at hand. Yet, when the teacher had them using Google Docs or an interactive Powerpoint, they didn’t want to stop. Technology is not going anywhere. It will likely become more prevalent and integrated in the lives of future students no matter how hard someone may fight it. Rather than being behind the times and resisting, I think it is important to use it as a selective learning tool. Which is to say that a classroom does not need to be completely reliant on it or completely abstain, but I think to strike a balance between the two would be a key to unlocking student engagement. Much like the coveted days in school when teachers would play movies in class, I think are the times where we allow for the use of technology in a constructive way.

Hoag talks about re-framing the relationship between students and technology into something positive. “Although technology-use may derail one’s initial educational aims, as teachers and students, it is within our capacity to redefine and reframe the rhetoric involved, not only putting into question our aims themselves, but cleansing our teaching and learning more generally from derisive moral judgment and retributive discipline, thereby vitally, “mercifully,” modifying our pedagogical attitudes and practices” (Hoag, last paragraph). To take it a step further would be to integrate the technology-use so it does not have the opportunity to derail educational aims. Redefining it also takes away the shame, moral judgement, and inability for an individual to possess control/power over their “addiction”. The power dynamic is shifted so that they are not seen as “helplessly addicted” to something that is a necessity in contemporary society. I wouldn’t know what to change the terminology to but ultimately it is a shift from negative to positive, helpless into an assertion of research, knowledge, and power. Technology has the ability to maintain connections, connect more people, and keep discussions that are occurring within the classroom outside of the classroom. It is possible for collaboration or continued learning with others around us, and so I think it is important to discontinue the use of “addiction” when referring to students and technology.

There are more people in my family who have substance addiction than those who do not, which makes it particularly challenging for me when it comes to considering students as technology “addicts”. I undeniably felt resistance with the terminology discussed for technology users. I am not sure where I sit with the idea of individuals being “addicts of technology”. It seems to me that it is something deeply complicated, and I agree with Hoag in that “[he makes an assumption that] anyone who has struggled with “addiction” themselves, or loved and cared for someone who has, is likely going to be (or should be) more hesitant to employ the rhetoric of addiction/drugs in relation to technology” (fourth paragraph up from the bottom). I think that is the best way to describe my view toward calling people addicts of technology, and rather I would hope that there could be a more positive term to characterize individuals (especially if they have a need) who use technology frequently.

Previous Article
Next Article