Thinking About the Social Conditions and Shame in the Classroom
For RR this week, I am thinking more about the hierarchical construction of higher education, and the reinforced divide between the knowledgeable professor, and the ignorant student (per Ranciere HERE). I keep trying to picture higher education without this hierarchy and it makes me wonder if egalitarianism is possible in school. I wonder what more students need in order to abolish this divide. Moreover, how may I facilitate an environment where students’ wills propel themselves in the absence of constraint?
So, I read more about the challenges students may face from this divide in Leslie Bayer’s article, “Student Shaming and the Need for Academic Empathy” in Hybrid Pedagogy. The article answers my inquiry, as many social conditions in the classroom are counter-intuitive to egalitarianism, and pose constraints. For example, professors may shame students for their colloquial language (griped about in the article “U Can’t Talk to Ur Professor Like This”). Some professors require the students address them by last name, while that same professor insists on addressing students on a first name basis. These social standards reflect the respect that learned intellectuals do, in fact, deserve. But they also send students a dangerous message of perpetual inadequacy, that they will lack what the professor has, that their language is not as valued. As mentioned in our class, this shuts off the autonomous will to learn autonomously. Bayer says that students feel “beaten down” due to such social politics.
Bayer illuminates more about how professors shame students, both on purpose and inadvertently. A lot of this shame is couched in how modern students communicate with the advent of social media, because there is now a bigger divide between “proper” academic writing, and student expression online. This is more motivation for me to incorporate social media into my future pedagogy–to meet students’ expressions where they already are.
Bayer points out that educators also endure the same shame and denial that we perpetuate onto students. She says, “there are so many opportunities to feel ‘less than’ within academic culture: an idea dismissed by teachers, colleagues or classmates; a job not gotten; a promotion not granted; a voice ignored in a meeting; the article rejected or book not published.” So it seems that shame and denial are built into our educational system. What’s more tricky, is that we tend to blame students for their own lack of authentic engagement. So the blame and shame trickles from the top down.
Bayer gives many tools in the article to abolish the shame of both the educator and the student, and close the hierarchical gap. She recommends a model that incorporates:
- transparency, where the teacher assures the students of their own capabilities, and the teacher’s goals for a given activity. She says, “Ensuring that students understand why they are being asked to do the various assignments in your course can result in more careful work.”
- Adopting a “coaching” mentality rather than a judgmental one, and communicating a judgment-free attitude to the student.
- Prompting frequent student reflection, which leads the student to “fuse” their personal experience with the activity at hand. I can see how this would make students feel like their voice matters, and that they belong in the conversation apologetically.
Bayer notes that these methods aren’t fix-alls. I think that the shame issue goes deeper than pedagogy, as I mentioned above that professors feel this shame too, perpetuated on them by the larger institutional conditions of higher education. I’m not sure what the solution should be, but I’ll keep thinking about it. I think the shame and hierarchy issues are all rooted in capitalism, which perpetuates competition and shames the “have-nots” but that assertion calls for a much larger discussion…