Reading Room “Beyond the Five Paragraph Essay”
Kimberly Hill Campbell, a former high school teacher and a current associate professor in Education, argues against the five-paragraph essay formula. Based on her research over thirty years and in-class experience, she finds that the formulaic approach to writing does more harm than good to students. While the formula helps students organize their thoughts, it simultaneously limits their thought process and leads them to write rather a shallow essay because students tend to squelch ideas that do not neatly fit into the body paragraphs. In order to move beyond this formula, Campbell suggests that teachers help students develop deep thinking while they read the texts they are writing about.
One of the suggestions is for teachers to encourage close reading among students. She asks students to pick a particular passage, track specific proper nouns, adjectives, or verbs, and examine what information each word conveys. I think this is a great exercise for students to be aware of how to read and be conscious of style, of diction, of sentence structures, creating a plot, and creating characters. Of course, students cannot do this for the entire novel, but I think it’s important to walk them through the process at least once. That way, they know how to do close-reading on their own and develop the skills over time.
Another way to develop a close reading skill is for teachers to encourage students to ask questions as they read. The questions can include “personal (what connections can I make to this text?); form/craft (what techniques does the author use, and to what effect?); comparative (how does this text compare/contrast with other texts); or critical (why does this text matter)”? (63). Learning to pose questions is critical because it allows readers to engage in a dialogue with the text. But before students learn to pose questions on their own, they need to get in touch with their curiosity. Sometimes, students are not interested in the text or resist learning; this makes me wonder how to help students become curious about the subject in the first place. Without curiosity, there is no possibility of engagement or doing close-reading.
This close reading is coupled with low-stakes writing assignments where students are given opportunities to explore their thoughts and figure out what they want to say about a given topic. The key here is to create a formula-free argument that helps develop their thoughts. A teacher can ask students to respond to quotes or prompts from a text they are focusing on. After a several of these low-stakes writing, the teacher asks students to revisit those writing assignments, help them figure out what they want to prove in their essay, and prompt them to think of patterns they find or things they find intriguing. I appreciate this step-by-step guideline as to how to help students develop their thoughts and put them into writing. I think it also helps that the teacher does not ask students to come up with a thesis at this point. Rather students should focus on finding out what questions they might want to answer and what types of evidence they need.
The author concludes the paper with a warning that students may resist this type of writing training. Her students resisted and demanded her to switch back to the five-paragraph essay. This reflects the fact that most students are trained in Escartz learning, where they rely on formula and thus avoid thinking deeply. Even if students resist, I believe it is well worth to implement free-formula-writing styles so that they have a chance to develop their original thoughts rather than putting their thoughts neatly into the box where contradictions or subtleties cannot exist. As we saw in the Escartz learning essay, it doesn’t serve students in the long run, so it’s better to intervene earlier than later to help them move away from formulaic thinking.