Reading Room #6: Draftback as a Tool for Metacognitive Reflection

As a First Year Composition instructor a valuable skill I try to teach my freshman students is how to metacognitively reflect on their writing process: i.e. noting what works for them, what doesn’t, and what lessons to add to their personal writing tool kits. In the article, “Draftback to the Future: A Tool for Writing Process Analysis,” Elizabeth Chamberlain introduces “Draftback,” a Google Chrome application and extension download of Google Docs, that allows students to view edits they make to a writing piece composed in Google Docs. This extension application allows students to watch how their writing project changes due to edits through a playback feature. This feature, comes with the option for the student to record a narration that can act as a “think aloud.” Chamberlain suggests Draftback to be an effective tool for students to reflect and learn about their writing process, as it provides data writing studies often look for. Some examples of editing data found by Draftback include global and local changes, times the student experienced writer block, length of pauses, deletions, and any moments of distractions.

Although Chamberlain found Draftback as a helpful tool for analyzing one’s own writing process, there are a few disadvantages to the program:

– Students found it difficult to create an “embed,” which is the last step of retrieving the data and condensing it into a shareable file.
– Google Doc’s terms of use include the right to access the data. Although the creator of Draftback suggests Google is not likely to share or misuse the data, the provision may make users weary.
– Students often found they were too close to the data, making it harder to analyze. Chamberlain suggests having students evaluate each other’s Draftback data.

The most revealing finding by Draftback data is the confirmation that writing is a recursive process which occurs during all stages of writing, rather than waiting until the very end to make edits. Another crucial finding is the data shows that writers are often their own enemies, creating distractions and fighting themselves.

This is my first time hearing about Draftback. I am going to add this program to my repertoire of technological tools to help and teach writers. The software sounds appealing and the data can provide students with insight into their own writing process. I’m interested in trying this program for myself and I’m eager to learn how other teachers implement it in their writing programs.

Previous Article
Next Article