RR for 10/16: The Reader/Writer Relationship
This week I read “When We Are Writers,” an article by Sean Michael Morris from Hybrid Pedagogy (of course)- I’ve been gravitating a lot towards articles in this journal for some reason. It is an abstract, free-flowing article, and I was excited for the journey it took me on.
Well, Morris tells an anecdote of a young boy and his father in a Starbucks. The son doesn’t obey his father commands to sit still. After several attempts to make the son behave, the father takes away the son’s cookie as punishment. The boy cries because he lost his cookie and eventually the two leave the coffee shop. Morris notices that as they leave, the boy “has something to say” but the father sadly ignores him repeatedly. I think Morris identifies with this child, because he also wants his voice to be heard as a writer. But the act of writing does not have to be as isolated as this child feels– in fact, good and thoughtful writing is a result of cultural and social immersion. And so is authentic reading! I am most taken with this anecdote because I think the child embodies the role of the reader in a class. Readers look for art that allows for their active engagement, so as to “talk back” to the text among others in a community. The story of the boy is important on a pedagogical level, because canonical texts in top-down methods of instruction are the God-like structures that take away the student’s cookie.
I like Morris’ anecdote because it demonstrates that writing does not exist in a vacuum. Writing makes one pull from their own understandings of the world, and more importantly people and cultures they may know, whether from texts or real life. Morris says, “Is it the writer’s job to live…To be part of culture… in even more intimate ways than those who don’t write.” I think he gets to the purpose of both reading and writing here. That is to inspire and develop varying perspectives of people who live in our world. Writers are armed with the power of language and expression for those who read, and thereby pass on those powers to those who read.
To me, Morris conveyed the story of the young boy to both show his compassion for the boy’s stifled experience and to pose a pedagogical problem: educators should be meeting students in their worlds, because those readers “have something to say,” too. We should allow as much space for their reactions as we allow for the voices of the writers. In short, literature teaches nothing if there is no space to communicate about it on a deeply personal level.
I am taking a Quixotes class with professor Hackenberg this semester and I can’t stop thinking about the blurred line between the roles of reader and writer; how different are they if at all? The reader writes his own world with language in the exact way that a writer does, incorporating their own contextualization from literature and real life. I think I agree with Morris that neither reading nor writing should require cultural isolation or silence… how boring and sad would that be!