Reading Room 10/23

Is it Incivility or Mental Illness? Understanding and Coping with Disruptive Student Behavior in the College Classroom

From: Journal of Effective Reading

Trigger Warning

“This paper will focus on helping faculty to distinguish incivility from mental illness, and to develop effective strategies for coping with disturbing behavior” (McNaughton-Cassill 1).

The author links examples of school shootings to the perpetrators potentially having underlying mental health issues. They argue that graduate programs focus on content and the delivery of content more than interpersonal dynamics between teacher and student. This leads to “many faculty members [finding] themselves at a loss when they encounter a student who is disruptive, disrespectful, angry, excessively anxious, or irrational” (2). The author argues that future teachers need training when it comes to dealing with students who act in uncivil, potentially revealing ways that not only can cause a unproductive, unpleasant classroom environment but signify that there is a larger issue at hand. They advocate that teachers need to understand why the behavior is occurring, and address it in a  way that is appropriate, does not impede the class or cause an imbalance of class, and makes sure to consider the needs that the disruptive student may have that has caused such behavior.

The author goes on to talk about various types of behaviors and the perspectives of those who dislike the behavior. As a student, I am able to reflect on times where others were disruptive to my learning, and it is uncomfortable address for you have to be considerate to the other person. The instances I have in mind are when students are playing games on their computers, texting (on their phone or computer), watching unrelated videos, or browsing the internet. The question of how to cease the distraction and who has the responsibility to do so can be uncomfortable, whether you are the student experiencing it, the student who is told that they are distracting with inappropriate classroom behavior, or the teacher, depending on the outcome, having to tell the student. That could potentially be problematic, for the teacher is revered at a higher hierarchical level than a student, an can cause unpleasantness. This is a tricky matter to address, and perhaps that is due to my own character. It may cause unpleasantness, and often students feel as though other students are “snitching” or “tattling” when they bring up the behavior as distracting, even if it is privately and anonymously addressed. This all takes place on a level where it is incivility, and when issues that relate to other students’ mental heath, it becomes higher stakes.

The author talks about how it is not realistic to ask faculty to be able to diagnose mental health issues, but recognizing behavior that deviates from the ‘norm’ or is inappropriate is possible. Not only being able to recognize these problems as they arise through patterns or behavior but being self-aware as a faculty member (in case the behavior escalates to behavior that can affect their person) is a necessity. In large, the article is arguing that future teachers need training to know the difference between incivility and underlying mental health issues. This can lead not only to the teacher being able to control the incivil behavior within the classroom more effectively, but addressing the student’s needs, regardless from where it stems from. This can help to maintain and promote an environment where students are able to learn more effectively in addition to working with the student who is disruptive to either understand the behavior and work with it or to seek/recommend professional help from them. Considering the rise in school shootings, it seems that the author is suggesting that with proper training, perhaps these incidents could have been avoided and the students could have gotten the help they needed.

I agree that this type of training is not only something that seems highly important, but beneficial for all parties involved. Considering students all come from complex and diverse backgrounds, it is hard to be able to analyze and understand every aspect of them while they are in a class for a few hours (or more, depending on the institution or grade level) a few times or less a week. The training would ideally help faculty to be able to identify problematic or undesired behavior and to have the skill set to be able to either investigate in a way that does not aggravate the student/behavior further or to recommend intervention when necessary (by a group with a specialized skill set). Having worked at a restaurant for 9 years, I can say that while practice made me successful at handing nearly every scenario I encountered, there will always be exceptions to the case. Nothing is ever predictable or out of the question when it comes to people and their behaviors, and it it not only in the best interest of the person who is experiencing it, the party they are interacting it, and those around to have a knowledge or tool in which they can rely on to be able to maintain control in the situation but in the cases where the person does not know what to do, they are able to contact someone who has background with such dealings. Even if the class would require extra money or time, I – and I feel may of my colleagues – would have a desire to take a class in which could provide this training. Overall, it seems beneficial, and in theory it seems that avoiding larger issues is a potential possibility.

Previous Article
Next Article