Discussion Reflections: Teaching “The Wasteland”
Tuesday’s discussion really got me thinking about the difficulty students face in T.S. Eliot’s “The Wasteland.” Moreover, our discussion made me think of the broader (psychological) difficulties that meet us when we read poetry in general. What happens when the poem lacks a certain grounding that students find comfortable? What happens when the poem is made up from fragmented topics, history, emotions, and imagery? Eliot’s poem is particularly challenging and therefore ripe for teasing out these questions in a pedagogical sense. Calling on Salvatori, I found that assigning “The Wasteland” becomes a means to challenge students’ reading habits in self-reflexive ways. Thinking of Backwards Design, I gained insight on appropriate “evidence” of student learning paired with difficult texts.
If I may loosely quote, Professor Hanley mentioned that poetry ‘is about things, but also does something to the reader’ and it is therefore transactional. The reader transforms and experiences and the text does not (and should not) stand alone. I would implement an annotative “difficulty activity” rather than a difficulty paper because I think it is so important for students to express their difficulties rather than ignore them. Difficulty is an essential part of the reading process and signals a need to investigate.
Before coming to class on Tuesday I thought a group-oriented annotation assignment would be helpful for addressing the overwhelmingly fragmented nature of the poem. (At least this is what helped me cope at first). I pulled up the Hypothesis plugin intending to annotate, but I ended up tracing the annotations that others had left before. I was able to trace images found in the age-old Holy Grail tale for instance. Once done tracing each thread in the annotation comments, I was met with new threads to follow. I felt frustrated and thought to myself that I’d never be able to extrapolate on each thread and find out what the poem is really about. That’s when I came to a realization–perhaps the poem is meant to destabilize every comfort I have in reading poetry. We spoke in class about how this jumbled and fragmented effect is characteristic of modernist art as well. Perhaps it is not supposed to make sense the way we expect it… And the student does not necessarily have to follow every thread in the work in order to experience, or be transformed. I found this realization to be depressurizing and relieving. Students reading poetry should know that a poem is not a thing to be resolved. I find this to be a helpful goal paired with a “tracing” assignment conducted in groups.
Overall, I find Salvatori’s push for self-reflexivity especially helpful in thinking about difficulty. I would alter my group annotation “thread tracing” idea. The overall goal would be to take the pressure off of the students by helping them realize that: 1) Their difficulties are essential and important, and 2.) The fragments are purposeful, and therefore don’t require a grand resolve.