Reading Room 11/6
Caring In Teaching: A Complicated Relationship
By Margaret Barrow
From the Journal of Effective Teaching
I really loved this article. It talks about teachers trying to help students by putting their needs first. The author then goes on to give vignettes as examples of what they encountered and the different types of students. I would highly recommend this article. It also includes a short section in which the (potential) controversy of the student-teacher relationship is explored.
The author argues that it is rewarding to see a student succeed (in whatever way that may be), and that there is not a singular path of success. Additionally, not all students are going to have the background in which college is something they’re able to take on due to personal reasons and college may not be the right route for the student (one of their students went on to get a real-estate license in lieu of school).
I think this article serves as a reminder that just because education was the path for the teacher, meaning they are in this role because they have a degree, it is important to listen to students and serve their best interest. The author does caution that “teaching with a care ethic involves a serious time and emotional commitment, and the pressures to be an “effective” and “good” teacher and meet professional commitments are, at the very least, challenging” (Barrow 10). That was the thing that made me the most curious, for I was unsure how the author was able to take on the different lives and needs of their students. Being a tutor at the LAC, I have instances where my personal life or needs have to be put aside to focus on the needs of my students. Additionally, I have had instances where students simply want someone to listen to them about school, their experience, or their life. I am already experiencing on a very small level what I believe this emotional/time commitment is, and I am curious how teachers are able to balance the large amount of work that is required for teaching courses in addition to this. I worked in the food industry for 8 years, and that required little to no emotional commitment (the time way unpredictable and tolling on my physical self). Now that I am in a role that requires increased levels of work with students, it is a change that I am still learning how to navigate. I imagine that becoming a teacher will increase that again, and I think it is important to have teachers who are ready to commit to the idea.
Having a course in which the unseen tasks a teacher encounters would be useful. There is a huge emphasis on pedagogy – which is an absolute necessity – but I think it would be valuable to offer a course that talks about the ideas that are brought here in relation to working with students. Understanding the boundaries that need to exist, the cautions that go with it, and how to balance the student’s needs with self-care are challenges that are important and could result in worthwhile discussion. Furthermore, this would give future teachers the opportunity to possibly form relationships with peers in which they could support one another. The Professor(s) teaching the course could offer examples or real scenarios and discuss ways in which to navigate everything. I am unsure what this might look like, but I would appreciate a chance to become more informed of the most effective ways in which to help students and their needs, and I think this article is a good start toward that consideration.