Response to Adam Heidebrink-Bruno’s “Syllabus as Manifesto: A Critical Approach to Classroom Culture”

In this article, Heidebrink-Bruno reflects on how syllabi have become a bureaucratic requirement that is boring and makes the classroom atmosphere boring as well and how “a syllabus should be a manifesto that serves as a founding document detailing the rights of the students and the pedagogy of the classroom.” With that in mind, he argues that the syllabus should create the space for cultural exchange. His main problem with the standard format of syllabi is that “it provides information without its cultural and historical contexts” and, Therefore, “appears isolated and meaningless.” He also argues that office hours build barriers between students and teachers since it provides less opportunity for casual conversation and demands that the students ask only important questions so as not to waste the teacher’s time. Furthermore, he believes that simple grading charts represent the tendency to “reward lesser acts of accomplishment” because students tend to choose a safer route academically in order to achieve higher grades. Heidenbrink-Bruno believes that a good syllabus “should prove to be a useful educative artifact, embedded with rich cultural and political meaning worthy of much time and contemplation.”

This is a really interesting article that brought up arguments that I, quite frankly never even considered before. I never took issue with the formats of the syllabi I had received thus far, and I often find them to be really helpful guides throughout the semester. However, in looking at the sample syllabus that he provided, I can see that his format is far more intriguing, thought-provoking, and contextual. One section that he provides in the syllabus that I’ve never seen before is called “Right of the Learning Community (Always a Partial List)” and there he goes over some of the basic rights that all learners in an academic institution should have. Also, in the grading section, he does not simply provide a chart explaining how he will divide up the grade. Rather, he explains in full sentences how his grading system works and how he is more interested “in the social, civil, and cultural values associated with learning” which are not usually graded.  For the office hours, he goes into making it clear that he will always be available for students, even if it means setting up virtual meetings, and for attendance, he explains why it’s important for students to be present in the classroom as it is important for a “meaningful education.” What I appreciate most about this article is that it does provide the reader with an example of how he believes a syllabus should look. Had he not provided one, I doubt that his message would have come across as strong and I would have misunderstood some of the things he discussed. It also provides me with a well-written syllabus that I could use as a guide in the future.

Previous Article
Next Article