Reading Room #8: “The Art of Giving Online Feedback”

As a M.A. Composition student and now, a First Year Composition instructor, the feedback I provide to my students has certainly come a long way. In our field we are encouraged to provide frequent and clear feedback so that students will understand the importance of revision, and they will view writing as a recursive process. Although I have taken a comprehensive course dedicated to responding to student writing, I believe it’s important to keep up to date on scholarship surrounding feedback, because “effective” feedback may sometimes feel just as vague to us, as it may feel to students

This week I read the article, “The Art of Giving Online Feedback” by Nancyruth Leibold and Laura Marie Schwarz (2015), from The Journal of Effective Teaching. Although geared towards online instruction, the authors provide Best Practices for providing feedback online. They describe “online” as: written word, audio, video, or live conferencing–the use of technology. Since this is my first year teaching, it has taken some time to become familiar with iLearn and other online learning tools. My students use iLearn to submit their homework (and I have given them feedback on those assignments online), but have submitted essay drafts and final drafts via printed hardcopy. I am interested in implementing online feedback some time in the near future. Some of the other GTAs are already using online feedback in their classrooms.

It’s important to note that the authors cite in the article that 56% of a 2014 study found “positive feedback” as not helpful for improving their work. The authors state the results may have been unique to that study, and still stick to their argument to have an overall “positive” tone when commenting.

Some of the advantages to using audio or video feedback formats include saving time (it is faster to speak a comment than to write it); More participants reported more clarity of audio/video comments; and it lead to more personalization, something that was especially important in an online class that did not meet face-to-face. Another way of saving time includes keeping a comment bank, which consist of general comments that can be cut and pasted into other students’ work, and kept for future use (34).

The most important takeaways are the Best Practices compiled by the authors. The Best Practices for Providing Online Feedback are the following:

1. Address the learner by name: This also helps with personalizing the learning experience.

2. Provide frequent feedback: In an online course, it is more effective if a teacher can make a pattern for providing feedback, like every Wednesday.

3. Provide immediate feedback: The authors recommend 72 hours from a discussion, and within a week for paper/project assignments. This allows the information to remain fresh in students’ minds.

4. Provide balance feedback: This means a balance of what the student has done well, and what the student still needs to improve.

5. Provide specific feedback: The authors use the example, “The second paragraph on page 4 includes helpful information that is explained in clear terms.” This is especially important in an online course, so that students can identify the spot you are commenting on. Also, this kind of specificity is helpful for teachers to improve their comments.

6. Use a positive tone: The authors recommend that 2/3 of the comments should be positive, pointing out what the students did correctly.

7. Ask questions to promote thinking: This calls on the student to use concrete examples, or asks them to expand their knowledge (37).

Another nuanced tip, is to save positive, “praise” comments for private, online chats, where only the students will see your comments. Then, use constructive, improvement-based comments for online forums where all students can view your comments. The authors state other students may benefit from seeing each others’ comments for improvement.

I will use this knowledge when I begin to use online feedback in my classroom. I strive to be a reflexive practitioner, always seeking to improve my comments and the way I teach. I believe technology can enhance learning in the classroom, and I build my course around the use of technology as tools and aids in learning. However, in the back of my mind, I constantly think about student accessibility. This semester I have had a few students struggle with iLearn, and I had to wonder if it was an issue of not having access to a computer for regular use at home. Still there must be a balance because technology, and being able to keep up with it in the postsecondary level, is vital to success.

Previous Article
Next Article