Response to Annotation Comrade

Reflection on “The United States Welcomes You” By Tracy K. Smith

I read the response to my assignment from my Annotation Comrade on “The United States Welcomes You” by Track K.Smith.  In recent discussions of immigration policies in the United States, a controversial issue has been the treatment of immigrants coming into the country. On the one hand, some argue that if they come through the borders illegally, they should be sent back home. From this perspective, the poem from Smith was a very good way to introduce immigration policies to the classroom, so as to know the real implications of crossing borders into the country, especially if this is a minority group that isn’t wanted. According to the comrade, this was a new poem for her because she immediately started making parallels between social movements and activism in a bid to fully understand the assignment’s objective. From her reflection, it was quite interesting to make these comparisons especially the concepts of analyzing two marginalized groups; #BlackLivesMatter and immigration.   

Smith talks about the issues immigrants face when they come into the United States, which is an irony because the title of her poem talks about being welcomed in to the country. I wanted my comrade to make a connection about how building walls across migration borders can immediately alienate minority groups, especially with the reports that has been circulating in the media. My annotation comrade said the poem encourages a deeper reflection on migration policies in the United States. I wanted to demystify the importance of looking at how minority groups are usually portrayed as inferior by providing the actual policies that was introduced by the Trump administration.

I also added a photo, a video from the poet reading from the poetry collection and also a link to the Radical Teacher journal that reflects on how the #BlackLivesMatter movement and activism is fully enacted in classroom syllabi. I provided my analysis of the #BlackLivesMatter movement, posing it as a question to my comrade to make connections and show how minority groups are usually at a disadvantage within the borders of white supremacy policies.

My annotation partner was able to think of new ways to include activism into the classroom and took the exercise a step further by including an article called Literary Flowers that bridges 17th and early 21st century literature to bring together quotes from famous activists. This exercise went beyond my expectations, because my comrade was able to make important connections between social movements and time periods to analyze her study of literary conventions. She also talks about almost forgetting to annotate the poem, and I guess I may have distracted her a bit with the link to the #BlackLivesMatter article.  I agree with my comrade that this exercise was “intellectually stimulating and emotional,” and hopefully we can talk about this exercise in a class discussion.

Previous Article
Next Article