Reading Room #9: How Much Risk Are You Willing to Take as a Teacher?

I read the article, “Disruptive Pedagogy and the Practice of Freedom,” written by Julie Fellmayer, found in the journal Hybrid Pedagogy. This article begins by quoting James Baldwin’s Talk to Teachers :

“The purpose of education, finally, is to create in a person the ability to look at the world for himself, to make his own decisions… What societies really, ideally, want is a citizenry which will simply obey the rules of society. If a society succeeds in this, that society is about to perish. The obligation of anyone who thinks of himself as responsible is to examine society and try to change and fight it—at no matter what risk. This is the only hope that society has. This is the only way societies change.“ (Baldwin, 1963).

The author encapsulates the essence of Critical Pedagogy, as she quotes, amongst Baldwin, Paulo Freire and Bell Hooks. Baldwin’s quote seems just as relevant today as it did in 1963. I am especially interested in this article because Critical Pedagogy plays a huge role in my own teaching goals and philosophy. Using Bell Hook’s idea of a teacher’s “self actualization,” Fellmayer recognizes her own privilege, stating that her life seems to fit the accepted societal norms (she states that she is white, straight, cis-gendered, able-bodied, middle-class, and married). She makes the connection to Maslow’s Hierarchy of Human Needs, reaching the top portion of the pyramid of “self-actualiztion,” because her physiological, safety, belonging, and esteem needs have been met (3). She then ponders how she can ask her students to self-actualize their own lives, if she cannot empathize with their transgressions.

Still, she states this is an important part of the conversation. She believes that students need to learn how to participate in a democracy, and become intellectually aware enough to make changes in society. This kind of teaching, requires politics to enter the conversation. Students must realize that higher education means fighting for freedom (4). This kind of teaching, however, also involves risk. It requires teaching students how the system/status quo works, and what they can do to fight oppression. With this kind of conversation, and thinking about the political climate, this kind of teaching may lead to “rocking the boat” or a kind of tension that comes along with discussing marginalization.

Understanding that it may be more comfortable to just go with the flow, stay within one’s comfort zone, and to follow the system, Fellmayer views this type of teaching as an aspiration, and not yet fully practiced. She urges for teachers to revisit the words of Baldwin, and to make these important “political” decisions (She states that the conscious decision to omit politics in the classroom is still a decision). One suggestion is to have a course built around marginalized voices.

This article has been eye-opening for me. As I want Critical Pedagogy to be a part of my course, I need to establish how much of a risk I am willing to take in order to have these kinds of conversations with my students. As this is my first semester teaching, I may wait until I have been hired on as an instructor, and establish certain things such as what my teaching persona is, what school I am teaching at, what our college’s mission statement is, what my department is like, etc. before I can establish how much risk I can take. But this article serves as a reminder to make these types of decisions, and consider what knowledge you want your students to leave your class with. Like this article suggested, this idea of “learning as freedom” is an ideal, but worth aspiring to.

Previous Article
Next Article