Let’s try to finish reading Attaway’s Blood on the Forge by Tuesday.
In class, we started talking about the differences between Duke Ellington’s “Tiger Rag” and Robert Johnson’s “Hellhound on My Trail.”
Some of the differences you pointed out: slow (blues) vs. fast (jazz) [temporality]; sad (blues) vs. happy (jazz) [affect] ; individual performer (blues) vs. collective performer (jazz) [social organization]; permutations on the performer – audience relations.
Let’s think some more about these differences between the two forms of African-American music. Listen to the two songs again. What kinds of differences can you note between the songs? Start with particulars and details. Keep track of these.
After you’ve collected differences between the two songs, think about the following question: to what extent can we organize these differences in terms of a “folk” versus “modern” aesthetic? E.g. to what extent do these differences reflect differences between folk and modernist cultures (and the ways we think about this difference: rural vs. urban, traditional vs. new, oral vs. literate, etc.)?
Write this up. E.g. on a couple of pages: jot down your list of differences; write up a paragraph or two speculating about how these aesthetic differences might reflect broader cultural differences (between “folk” and “modern” cultures).
Now, turn to our two painters, Aaron Douglas and Jacob Lawrence. The question here is: how does a reading of Johnson vs. Ellington help us to make sense of the different aesthetics in Douglas’s work vs. Lawrence’s? In other words, to what extent might Lawrence be painting through a “folk” aesthetic and Douglas through a “modernist” aesthetic? How might we see these aesthetics as “translating” from one media to another – – e.g. from music to art?
Again, write up a couple of paragraphs about Douglas vs. Lawrence.
Thus, you should come to class on Tuesday with some notes on paper. These notes do not have to be typed. Nor, do they have to be written in super correct English. Instead, think of them as a record of your thinking and work and as a starting point for a discussion about Blood on the Forge.
Leave a Reply