For Thursday (4/6) and Tuesday (4/11)

Could it be that we’re actually a little ahead of ourselves on the syllabus?  Looks that way.  This means we can slow down a bit and take our time with the next couple of novels – – which both, by my reading, revise the classical detective narrative, but in different ways.

For Tuesday, read at least up to the end of Section 02: “Integration” (Page 89 in my version) of Jeff VanderMeer’s Annihilation.   Some questions to consider as you read:

  • who is the detective in this narrative?  how does their work resemble and/or differ from the more “classical” detectives we’ve encountered so far?
  • last Tuesday, I elaborated a bit on the “hermeneutic code” as a way to understand detective/mystery narratives.  This term – – orignated by French literary theorist, Roland Barthes, in his seminal book, S/Z (a fun read, by the way) – – describes how narratives pose questions and engimas to the reader and how these elements actively pull/push a reader through a text in search of resolution.  (For instance, the “dead Roman in the bathroom” – – and the questions it poses: who is this guy? why is he in my bathroom? why me? – – is the initial engima that drives both Hector and the reader forward through the opening chapters of No Happy Ending.)  As you read Annihilation, keep track of the engimas posed by VanderMeer’s story to you, the reader, and/or to your surrogate – – the novel’s protagonist/detective.  As the text makes you ask questions, jot these questions down.  Typically, enigmas can be large or small – – but they must always initially present themselves as open-ended, thus pushing you and/or the protagonist to keep going in search of answers.  Bring this list of enigmas to class on Tuesday – – you can either write them down in pen/pencil or type/print them.

Sidenote: maybe because I’m an academic, I think one way of categorizing detective/mystery narratives is through their mix or ratio of hermeneutic and “proairetic” codes.  (Barthes uses “proairetic” code to describe the events that make up a story – – the plot summary, so to speak.  This “code” is more action-oriented.  For instance, a group of students arrives on an island; a former student on the mainland receives an odd note; a student on the island dies; the mainland student reunites with a former classmate;  the mainland student meets a helper – – Shimada; etc. etc.).  Mystery/detective narratives – – like most narratives – – contain and depend on both codes.  And, one way of categorizing mystery/detective narratives might be through the balance they strike between these codes: some mystery/detective narratives are more “action-oriented” (i.e. proairetic) – – e.g. hard-boiled or noir novels; others seem to be more “engima-oriented” (i.e. hermeneutic) – – e.g. Sherlock Holmes, the “chalet-in-the-snowstorm” or drawing room or domestic mystery, etc.. This is a just a hypothesis – – but it might be helpful in recognizing or adopting different reading styles and expectations and the variety of pleasures offered by the detective genre.