Reading Room 9/18: Classroom Discussion v. Online Discussion
For this week I read the article, “The Purpose of Online Discussion” by David Backer in the Hybrid Pedagogy Journal. Backer asks us: Can online discussion really compare to the rich conversation-based discussion that we experience in a physical classroom? How do we compare the two methods of dialogue? Or, is online discussion a viable dialogue at all? Backer points out that any online interaction is “mediated” through a screen. But aren’t classrooms also merely mediated by the containment of a class?
I wanted to read this article to continue thinking deeper about how modern students interact with one another and build schema. I think online discussion can be entirely fruitful, even more so than in the classroom. I’ll explain why I disagree with Backer on this point.
Backer says, “[Students] are looking at a screen (phone, tablet, laptop, desktop), reading the words of the online discussion rather than looking at a person and hearing words.” How important is hearing rather than reading, actually?– Because what I like about online discussion is that it provides the time and comfortable environment for students to articulate their thoughts and ideas. Some students suffer from mental health afflictions (anxiety, depression, PTSD etc.) that leave them in the dust as far as classroom discussion goes. Some students don’t feel comfortable asserting their ideas in the moment, or the moment passes them by because another student takes more control of the topic. I can’t imagine how many thoughts go unarticulated in a physical classroom. Classroom time can be fleeting, whereas online discussions allow for more time and safe space for thinking. What good is a thought if you don’t record it anyway? One may even revisit these published thoughts or draw from other students, responding in an organized fashion.
Backer thinks about the two methods in terms of psychoanalysis and ‘cathecting,’ he says, “I might think of my teacher like I think about my father or mother, or some authority in my life. I will definitely think about my computer quite differently.” But does a computer need to be an authority in order for students to articulate their ideas? Absolutely not! In fact, an authority often prevents students from participating in authentic discussion. An awareness of authority merely hinders originality and independent thought, simply consult Freire regarding “The Banking Method.”
More in support of real life classroom discussion, Backer also says, “ In an IRL discussion, students look, speak, and listen with multiple objects,”…. Ugh, as if online forums do not encourage the same if not more coherently! It depends on the site/forum/medium of online discussion of course, but as a student I definitely feel more in control of both: the content I read from others, and the way in which I express myself with language. I am, in fact, reading and responding to multiple ideas right now on an online platform! I argue that online discussions (if executed properly) encourage more participation among students, especially paired with proper facilitation of classroom discussion.