Response to Leslie Bayers and Eileen Camfield’s “Student Shaming and the Need for Academic Empathy”
In the article “Student shaming and the Need for Academic Empathy” published in Hybrid Pedagogy, Bayers and Camfield discuss the normalized public and private shaming of students in academic institutions which create toxic environments for learning. They argue that such mocking of students only adds to capitalistic ideas of competition and hierarchy which only “dehumanizes and commodifies students” and that such shame “not only hurts students but in fact also create barriers to equitable teaching and learning.” One major problem that Bayers and Camfield have in regards to this shaming is that it is often done in a way that limits or deprives students of responding or defending themselves, which makes teachers apathetic to students in general. They go on to discuss how such shaming is common among professors who then go on to shame their students which makes the world of academia a rather toxic one that is constantly being perpetuated by pessimistic professors. This, in turn, negatively affects students who come to believe that “failure is inevitable, causing them to give up before they begin”. Bayers and Camfield, however, provide their readers with ways in which this toxic culture can be changed into one that is more supportive than destructive. One is that they ask teachers to be more optimistic with their students and to try to create alternative narratives that might explain their students’ behaviors and actions which they deem to be flawed; thus creating since more empathy and understanding in the academic world. This article also offers a multitude of pedagogical approaches which humanize students such as “create an oasis,” “build community,” “choose depth over breadth,” etc. which aim to make the classroom more inviting for students and increase student interaction and confidence.
Reading this article reminded me of Huey P. Newton’s autobiography, Revolutionary Suicides. In this book, he describes why he wasn’t active in black student associations in college which he attributes to the shame that the leaders of these associations enforced on those who were not well learned in black history or in black struggle. For Newton, this initially pushed him away from wanting to partake in the movement since he did not want to feel embarrassed or ashamed for not having an understanding of a particular concept or experience. Newton takes this experience and writes, “I dissuade Party members from putting down people who do not understand. Even people who are unenlightened and seemingly bourgeois should be answered in a polite way. Things should be explained to them as fully as possible…I try to be cordial, because that way you win people over. You cannot win them over by drawing the line of demarcation, saying you are on this side and I am on the other; that shows a lack of consciousness.” My main takeaway from this article is that we need to show empathy towards our students. If they do something that we think should not be done in the academic field, if we want them to improve their critical, analytical, and writing skills, we must do it in a way that shows care and understanding. Being too harsh in our criticism and shaming students for not knowing things we think they ought to know is not only counter-productive because it pushes students away from wanting to know but also incredibly alienating as it creates a strong divide between teacher and student where the knowledge of the former becomes something that the latter deems unattainable.