Do we need learning outcomes during discussion?

“Believing we can plan student learning means we aren’t listening to them when they arrive,” (Friend).

 

For this week I’ve read and continued thinking about my reading room posts on 9/11 and 9/18 to build a nuanced understanding of critical thinking as a general goal. Now that we have read about working backwards in course design, I want to design methods that require students to develop more empathy–don’t we all though! I also want to consider how exercises that encourage critical thinking make students feel. Uncomfortable is my first guess.

I think most discomfort in school is indicative of  growth and intellectual discipline. I say that discomfort should be part of higher education- what is the point of college if not to challenge students to reevaluate and change their patterns of thought?  But I want to know what kind of discomfort is good rather than disengaging for students. Friend makes me think that I can hone discomfort (my own as a teacher as well as the discomforts of students) safely within classroom discussions as opposed to lectures.

In “Learning to Let Go: Listening to Students in Discussion,” Chris Friend says that this discomfort lives in the teacher as well. How does discomfort and the need to control come into play when we all contribute our thoughts, and anything can happen? How much control, if any, should teachers have on where the conversation goes?

Discussions can be confusing for both teachers and students because as teachers, we know that students expect us to guide their processes. They expect the Banking Method: they see themselves as walking capital. Sometimes students don’t know “what to do next” when we talk collectively in the classroom, and teachers lose their footing as a result. Discussion is a delicate ecosystem as I discussed in my blog for last week. Because students don’t plan and design courses, the responsibility to organize and communicate falls on us. So of course this article advocates for purpose driven discussion, but what should the purpose be?

Friend explains where he went wrong rather than right. He says, “I devoted more mental attention to where I wanted the conversation to go than I did to what my students were actually saying. I didn’t listen fully, with concentration and my entire self. I cheated them out of what they deserved: my attention.” (Friend). So I ask myself, is there a way to be too focused on the outcome of a design? Should the nature of discussion not lend itself to outcomes at all? I ask because it seems like a lot of our discomfort comes from losing control of the trajectory of discussion, and focusing on the end goal too much. When I TA’d last semester, I had the same anxieties as some of the students: how do I ask the right questions without telling them what to say? What if the discussion gets too off topic, or strays from my desired outcome? So I am struggling to understand what that balance looks like. Is it wrong to have desired outcomes for discussion when students are expected to be authentic with their original ideas?

Friend suggests digital tools that keep topics on track, while still encouraging students to learn authentically. An example of this is a communal notes page on google docs. The professor takes notes and asks questions on the doc outside of class, and records the varying responses while in class. Friend calls this a “digital whiteboard,” and I like this idea.

Friend says, “ I leave them to survive the conversation on the merits of their own contributions, not my guidance… [and] By taking notes, I show I’m listening,” and I like this method a lot in terms of course design because it is a more permanent point of reference (Friend). A technologically hybrid, community-based discussion can make the most out of discomfort and anxiety. As long as the teacher does not exert too much control…

 

Previous Article
Next Article