“Do You Trust Your Students?”

“Do you trust your students?” is a question posed by Amy Hasinoff, in her article by the same name, featured in Hybrid Pedagogy. She recounts her struggles as a newly-minted College Professor, to teach students that undermined her authority. To her chagrin, students would show up late, not complete the homework, talk over her, and would come to class unprepared. After reflection, she realized her course was designed for a student much like herself when she was in college, and not for a population of underprivileged students that were often the first of their families to go to college, had been away from school for a while, or had faced some sort of personal struggle. That is when she turned to Critical Pedagogy, Student-Centered Learning, and the idea of Self-Assessment for grading.

When it became apparent that her students did not care about the feedback she had taken so much time to give them, she began to look into Vicky Reitenauer’s work on self-grading. Hasinoff began to experiment using self-grading in her online course. She gave guidelines to her students for how they were to assess themselves on a weekly basis. Although structure and guidance was provided, self-assessment grading did not immediately go well because there was something that was missing between teacher and student—trust. Hasinoff did not completely trust her students based on past experiences; like one instance she left a quiz open for multiple attempts, only to have some students take a quiz up to 20 times until they got 100%. On the flip side, students did not buy into the idea that they could assess themselves, arguing the final grade would still be in the hands of the teacher.

It is at that moment that Hasinoff realized that trust needed to exist when it came to Critical Pedagogy and creating learning spaces where teachers and students can work together. “What if a student gives herself an A when she deserves a C?” is a point brought up when it comes to self-assessment. The response is that student would have to prove they deserve an A by showing evidence of their work. The pedagogical implication is that the lines of communication would open to have that discussion.

As an advocate for Critical Pedagogy myself, I am intrigued to learn that trust can be the underlying reason for tension in the classroom. Unlike Hasinoff, I consider myself an insider—I have personally overcome difficult circumstances, studied my way through community college, and struggled much of my adult life. If anything, as a teacher I can possibly become too trusting with the actions of students because of my self-proclaimed sense of empathy.

I have heard of Self-Assessment Grading before. It seems similar to Contract Grading. Although I am fascinated by these liberating ideals, I do not know how invested I am in these grading techniques. Especially as a teacher who is just starting out, I think it will take some time before I feel comfortable enough to even try something that nontraditional. My hesitation to adopt Self-Assessment is not because I want to reinforce my authority in the class, but rather, my inability to facilitate this grading handover in a purposeful, meaningful way.

My biggest takeaway from this article is the importance of trust, even when students act up. Trusting students is the heart of Critical Pedagogy. In the classroom, trust is a two-way street that cannot be assumed. Trust must be given to be received, and it is a pedagogical undercurrent.

Previous Article
Next Article