Reading Room #5: Teachers as “Hosts”

“What is your teaching persona?” is a question posed to me in my English 710: Curriculum Design course last semester. Although I can choose between certain terms such as “coach, model, facilitator, mentor, confidant, and/or advocate” (Roberge, Lockhart) to describe my ideal teaching style, I have come to realize that actually defining what kind of teacher I am in the classroom is a complex process that will take work, time, and practice to develop.

In the article, “Teacher-Student Relationships: A Model of Hospitality” (2013), Tana Schiewer discusses scholarship around the teacher-student dynamic, stating that in a student-centered classroom, there is a “third space” (Shapiro, 2009) where both teacher and students work toward a common goal. Schiewer elaborates on a fourth space called “transformative hospitality,” in which learning goals are achieved by the teacher acting as a hospitable host to students that are treated like guests.

Using the analogy of students as house guests, Schiewer suggests that the teacher, just like a host, should concentrate on the needs of the students/guests, without relinquishing all authority as teacher/home owner.

She suggests a good host will tell guests where the bathroom is. This kind of guidance or “directions” must also be given to students in the writing classroom. “They Say/I Say,” is a suggested book by Gerald Graff that guides students to using academic language. I am familiar with this book for Composition students. But I never thought to think of these scaffolds as a form of being hospitable.

Most importantly, Schiewer states that students must feel welcomed in our courses. She offers advice from Farber (2010) to be “fully present” in the classroom, rather than using our lesson plans to add on to the many technological “screens” students are inundated with; a challenge often faced by lecturers and teachers of big class sizes. Farber suggests teachers can do this by “befriending” their students.

Although Schiewer agrees with Farber, she warns against the danger of befriending our students. She argues that teachers must find a balance. She asserts students often don’t mind being told what to do as long as it is productive. She ties back to the analogy of the house guest who might try smoke in a non-smoking household—she states they will often not mind the compromise of going outside to smoke. Students too, will allow you to be the authority figure if it is “hospitable.”

Viewing the teacher as hospitable host is a new way of viewing the student-teacher dynamic. Schiewer argues that this approach has potential to build effective teaching. I have always sensed there is a certain quality found in the “effective” teacher, and this article offers a start to defining what that quality is.

Now that I am teaching English 114, I am recognizing the fine line between balancing authority and accommodation. I am passionate about teaching literacy, but I understand these students are transitioning into college, and need a certain amount of structure, and with that, comes a certain amount of authority. Although I have identified my persona as a “coach,” I have found that once in the classroom, your envisioned persona changes to the ebb and flow of circumstance—depending who your students are, what time your class meets, administration guidelines, your lesson plan, and so on. This article has given me a new lens to view the teacher-student relationship which I will use as I continue to build my evolving teaching persona.

Previous Article
Next Article

Reading Room #5: Teachers as “Hosts”

“What is your teaching persona?” is a question posed to me in my English 710: Curriculum Design course last semester. Although I can choose between certain terms such as “coach, model, facilitator, mentor, confidant, and/or advocate” (Roberge, Lockhart) to describe my ideal teaching style, I have come to realize that actually defining what kind of teacher I am in the classroom is a complex process that will take work, time, and practice to develop.

In the article, “Teacher-Student Relationships: A Model of Hospitality” (2013), Tana Schiewer discusses scholarship around the teacher-student dynamic, stating that in a student-centered classroom, there is a “third space” (Shapiro, 2009) where both teacher and students work toward a common goal. Schiewer elaborates on a fourth space called “transformative hospitality,” in which learning goals are achieved by the teacher acting as a hospitable host to students that are treated like guests.

Using the analogy of students as house guests, Schiewer suggests that the teacher, just like a host, should concentrate on the needs of the students/guests, without relinquishing all authority as teacher/home owner.

She suggests a good host will tell guests where the bathroom is. This kind of guidance or “directions” must also be given to students in the writing classroom. “They Say/I Say,” is a suggested book by Gerald Graff that guides students to using academic language. I am familiar with this book for Composition students. But I never thought to think of these scaffolds as a form of being hospitable.

Most importantly, Schiewer states that students must feel welcomed in our courses. She offers advice from Farber (2010) to be “fully present” in the classroom, rather than using our lesson plans to add on to the many technological “screens” students are inundated with; a challenge often faced by lecturers and teachers of big class sizes. Farber suggests teachers can do this by “befriending” their students.

Although Schiewer agrees with Farber, she warns against the danger of befriending our students. She argues that teachers must find a balance. She asserts students often don’t mind being told what to do as long as it is productive. She ties back to the analogy of the house guest who might try smoke in a non-smoking household—she states they will often not mind the compromise of going outside to smoke. Students too, will allow you to be the authority figure if it is “hospitable.”

Viewing the teacher as hospitable host is a new way of viewing the student-teacher dynamic. Schiewer argues that this approach has potential to build effective teaching. I have always sensed there is a certain quality found in the “effective” teacher, and this article offers a start to defining what that quality is.

Now that I am teaching English 114, I am recognizing the fine line between balancing authority and accommodation. I am passionate about teaching literacy, but I understand these students are transitioning into college, and need a certain amount of structure, and with that, comes a certain amount of authority. Although I have identified my persona as a “coach,” I have found that once in the classroom, your envisioned persona changes to the ebb and flow of circumstance—depending who your students are, what time your class meets, administration guidelines, your lesson plan, and so on. This article has given me a new lens to view the teacher-student relationship which I will use as I continue to build my evolving teaching persona.

Previous Article
Next Article