Dante Scholars Discover New Gateways into Heaven and Hell

In a recent issue of Pedagogy, a Duke University Press journal on teaching in English studies, the editors devoted seven essays–spanning more than sixty pages–to exploring “vertical approaches” to teaching Dante’s Divine Comedy.
The essays are the result of an ongoing project organized by The National Endowment for the Humanities Institute in Florence, Italy, which has brought together twenty-three faculty members and two graduate students from US institutions of higher learning, including community colleges, four-year liberal arts colleges, and research institutions, of which the primary criterion for selection was dedication to teaching, and the secondary, diversity of discipline. According to Project Director Brenda Deen Schildgen, “the goal of the institute was to enhance the teaching of Dante’s Comedy in great books courses and in disciplines outside Italian literature and language.”
In Schildgen’s “Why Teach Dante Vertically,” the first essay in the set of seven, she sheds light on the inherent limitations of the traditional approach scholars have taken to teaching the Comedy–an approach in which students are instructed to navigate the masterwork in linear order–canto by canto. Consequently, instructors often assign a section of cantos or limit class readings to one canticle.

Schildgen, who uniquely had a full year to digest the cantos, despairs for Dante’s modern readers, claiming, “Paradiso, which in many ways surpasses the earlier canticles in its intellectual and poetic achievement, remains the most difficult canticle and on the surface the least dramatic, so it rarely makes the syllabus.” She elaborates, “overwhelmingly, only Inferno ends up on the syllabus, thus giving students a rather limited and incorrect view of the spectrum of Dante’s accomplishment in the Comedy.”
In contrast, vertical readings approach the poem by theme rather than section. In courses on great books with only two weeks to navigate The Divine Comedy, instructors can cluster cantos by selected topics–for example, love and will, the histories of cities, or poetry and exile. The vertical approach also encourages students to think beyond the linear narrative and use retrospective, prospective, and introspective analysis in their readings, ways of seeing that Schildgen claims are fundamental to the Comedy.
While the NEH Institute is certainly not the first to use verticality as an analytic tool in Dante’s literature, the project espouses to be the first to design a vertical approach to the whole poem. “This systematic approach to interpreting the poem provides a wholly new way not just to read the poem,” Schildgen writes, “but to teach it across the three canticles.”
In order to promote this innovative approach to Italy’s most beloved poet, Schildgen says, “Cambridge University has invited thirty-three international Dante scholars to give public lectures focused on single canto vertical readings across the entire Comedy. Each talk examines three same-numbered cantos from the three canticles, making this the first major effort to pursue exploring the poem vertically. The talks have been followed by a three-volume book project, Vertical Readings in Dante’s Comedy, of which the first two volumes have appeared.”
Still in progress, the project hopes to bring vertical pedagogy to other literary works. The approach raises interesting questions not only about Dante and the academy’s interpretations of classics but also where instructors ought to bring their own views to bear on their subjects and how a work changes–for better or worse–when taken out of one frame and placed in another.