Response to Aisha Damali Lockridge’s “Practice and Performance: Teaching Urban Literature at the Less than Liberal Arts”

Lockridge begins her article by describing her experience as a Black woman professor at a liberal arts college with predominantly white and privileged students. At this college, she experienced many different forms of aggression because of her race and how she hoped her institution would support her. Unfortunately, that was not the case. Instead, she was asked to do tasks that were unreasonable, like mentoring every Black student on campus deal with the lack of attention and acknowledgment of the Confederate flags around them. At this college, she taught an urban literature class that began with famous Black literature like Wright’s Black Boy, and Walker’s Black, White, Jewish, progressed to a music project about Black music and its developments, and then to Souljah’s memoir No Disrespect. Whereas the students received everything prior to the memoir with enthusiasm and engagement, No Disrespect was not. The students refused to understand the subject matter and criticized Souljah’s “poor quality of writing, her questionable vocabulary, and aggressiveness in her tone.” This is what Damali says was her response to their resignation from the text:

Instead I righteously lectured them on how their privilege prevented them from seeing the world. Referring specifically to their interest in Hip Hop, I pointed out their seeming willingness to ignore the socio-political injustice, educational disadvantage, racism and prejudice that served as historical backdrop to music that laced through their iPods and of which they seemed so eager to demonstrate their superior knowledge in class. I told them that in rejecting Souljah’s text that they were participating in the continued cultural appropriation of Black culture, taking, using, and understanding nothing.

However, she later realized that instead of helping them understand the text more, she discouraged them, and she regrets “not doing more to facilitate a re-engagement with the text on their own terms.” She became more conscious of how the location and college in which she taught was not right for her since she wasn’t able to be the teacher she wanted to be because she found it limiting and started to believe that she was hired as part of a project to make the college staff seem more diverse and not because of her actual skills. She decided to leave that college and began working at a private university that was also predominantly white. But here, the staff was more diverse, and she was able to teach less conventional material with more success. She realized that such material “requires more labor: more preparation, more flexibility and as a result a safe space in which to do is not a luxury, it is a requirement.” She created courses that didn’t just expect students to understand her. Rather, she gradually introduced these unconventional ideas to them and they were able to follow her. For her, a big part of her pedagogical success is because she started teaching at a university where its goals did not displace hers.

What I find incredibly important about this article is that it reflects on how big of a role an institution plays in your teaching. We, as aspiring teachers, need to start considering what makes us feel comfortable and what kind of institution we plan to teach at. When I was a teacher, the school that I worked at was wonderful in many respects, but ultimately, the space was not a comfortable one, and the institution and its administration was a big part of that. So, yes, what and how we teach is significant and requires much attention and consideration, but so does where we teach.

Previous Article
Next Article