Reading Room 5: “An Assessment of Group Size in Interteaching”
Journal of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning: What is the impact of group size during interteach sessions compared with traditional teaching modules?
For Reading Room this week, I am interested in exploring Rocío Rosales and James L. Soldner’s article, “An Assessment of Group Size in Interteaching,” because it embraces a pedagogical model that highlights the importance of a classroom teaching model based on pair discussion (not peer discussions of a larger classroom group). I find this concept similar to having an annotation partner, because instead of having a larger peer group work on a text in the usual traditional lecture, two students are paired together into a one-on-one conversation with the assigned reading material. Interteaching according to Rosales and Soldner is a better method of teaching to ascertain whether students are truly engaging with the text, instead of piggybacking on others, because this ensures that every student is prepared before they come to a class discussion. The writers also argue that “pair discussions” are a more favorable method of training rather than other traditional teaching models, because students are better prepared in a “mutually informing conversation between two people” (Boyce & Hineline).
Furthermore, they say that for the concept of interteaching to be successful, there are several key components which should be taking into consideration: 1) preparation guides that generally serve as a study guide for students and cover a small amount of assigned reading material; 2) an in-class discussion with one classmate to review responses to the preparation guides completed before class; 3) completion of a record sheet to provide feedback to the instructor on the quality of the in-class discussion and topics that were most challenging; 4) clarifying lectures to cover class topics based on feedback provided on record sheets; 5) frequent test probes on the material from the assigned reading material and prep guides; and 6) quality points, a cooperative contingency whereby additional points are delivered if all members of a respective discussion group perform at or above a certain criteria on a question(s) or an entire test probe.
Outcomes of Interteaching:
Focusing on the preference for interteaching when compared to having a traditional lecture has had mixed reactions for students engaging with the text, because, according to Rosales and Soldner, the feedback suggests that some “student’s [recorded a] preference for interteaching while others reported a preference for lectures, even when interteaching was more effective (quoted in Querol, et al). The pair discussion component generally requires students to come to class prepared to interact with a classmate and during this discussion, students share information on preparing guides for each class period, and provide feedback on their discussion to the instructor. The authors also argue that “a growing number of studies have also shown consistent academic achievement when interteaching is used with no direct comparisons to lecture.”
I am interested in knowing why they are suggesting that students are becoming more comfortable with sharing information in a dyad rather than a larger classroom group. This will be a interesting conversation in our class discussions today Read the full article HERE