Reading Room #7: What’s in a Title?
In the article, “A Rhetoric of Titles: Eighteen forms for Student Writers,” (2014) Anne-Marie Womak discusses the importance of teaching students to appropriately develop titles for essays in Literature and Composition courses. As an instructor in introductory writing courses, Womak would find herself issuing the comment, “keep working on the title,” then moving her focus to other important elements of revision such as commenting on the thesis statement.
Some issues found in the titles of student essays include naming the essay after the work it is analyzing, such as “Romeo and Juliet.” Womak explains once the reader sees the title of the original work as the title of the essay, the reader will expect the original text to follow. Changing the title to “Analysis of Romeo and Juliet” would be a step in the right direction, but Womak suggests that including the word “analysis” sets up the reader to hefty expectations of a complete analysis of the whole original text. Then there are problems of titles that are too broad such as simply labeling an essay, “War.” (Womak, 370).
Womak describes her regret in treating titles as an “afterthought,” because she believes titles include two very important purposes in student essays— to introduce content and to reach the essay reader early. She offers eighteen “forms,” to help students improve their titles. Here are the first five of the forms:
1. Incorporate an appropriate quote from the text you analyze.
Example: “She Is a Creature Designed for Reading”: Narrative Intimacy in Young Adult Fiction.
2. List words in a series that name the elements you examine.
Example: Money, Love, and Aspiration in The Great Gatsby
3. Use parallel structure.
Example: Comic Women, Tragic Men: A Study of Gender and Genre in Shakespeare’s Plays
4. Play on a term that has multiple meanings. Example: No-Man’s-Land: Gender and Violence in Tim O’Brien’s “Sweetheart of the Song Tra Bong.”
5. Use a related cliché or recognizable phrase, either in its original form or in variation.
Example: I’ve Got My iPhone on You: Technology and Surveillance Culture in Gossip Girl
(Womak, 371-375).
The importance of teaching students to choose an appropriate title is emphasized because of the title’s ability to “forecast” content and tone of an essay. Womak then outlines the pedagogical importance of this skill, stating that it is a lesson in entering academic discourse through signposting (374). Hopefully giving students these types of “forms” or templates allows them to write with brevity; and to have them think globally about their writing and about their use of language (378).
After reading this article, I have started to think about my instruction as an English Education major. I don’t think I have had any explicit lessons in devising titles for essays. Perhaps one tip I received, which is the same tip I give to my students, is to wait until the paper is written to give the essay an original title. This article has opened my eyes to the importance of writing titles, especially when preparing students to become better writers (in preparation to enter their disciplines). I believe in challenging students and treating them as academics in training. This article highlights the importance of titles and how I can develop them for my own work, along with lessons on how to teach my students.