The Omega Men

We’ve looked at four different versions of I Am Legend: Richard Matheson’s original 1954 novella; the 1964 film version, Last Man on Earth with Vincent Price;  the 1971 remake, The Omega Man, with Charlton Heston; and, the latest remix, I Am Legend (2007) with Will Smith.  Your goal in this essay is to explain the significance of changes in the post-apocalyptic narrative over time – – i.e. what changes from version to version and what these changes mean or signify.

Your essay should be no more than two pages – – standard 8 1/2 by 11 paper, double spaced, font size no smaller than “12,” and one-inch margins.

The essay is due – – you’ll simply add the essay to your existing google doc – – by the beginning of class on Tuesday, March 7.

To accomplish your mission, you’ll want to:

  • start by choosing one concrete thematic or formal element shared by all four versions of the narrative.  Think of the work we did with the motifs of “the dog” and “the car” in our discussions of each version.  Other thematic motifs might include: the “new Eve” (Ruth/Lisa/Anna), setting, the house, the antagonist/s, “Ben Cortman,” the post-apocalyptic “hero,” etc.  (Remember, an absence can be as significant as a presence – – i.e. the absence of “the dog” in The Omega Man.)  “Formal elements” refers to things like: story beginnings and endings; setting; flashbacks; narrative structure; use of extra-diegetic effects like sound, and music.  Throughout our reading and discussion, we’ve touched on – – even if briefly – -most of these shared but mutated elements. (I’ve put up a page with some visual samples of some of these motifs.)
  • decide which versions of the “I Am Legend” narrative you want to discuss.  You don’t have to write about all four, but you should discuss at least three.
  • before you start writing, analyze your motif/element in detail – – noting small and big differences and similarities among the different versions of I Am Legend.
  • try to organize your essay around points of comparison and contrast, rather than the texts themselves
  • use specific examples to illustrate and develop your argument
  • avoid plot summary at all costs.  Think about your essay this way: you are making an argument about some particular motif – – any and all examples should be included only if they support or develop this argument.  Without an argument, you’ll probably end up just summarizing plot.
  • an ideal essay structure might look like this: three concise, efficient paragraphs analyzing your chosen motif and one concluding paragraph that explains the broader significance of these changes.
  • forget an introductory paragraph.  Your time and space is limited: just use one sentence to state the main idea of your essay.

You only have two pages to work with, so you must focus on being direct and efficient in your prose and analysis.  Draft and revise then revise some more.

To keep things compact, you can refer to our texts simply as: (IAL) for the original Matheson novella; (LME) for the 1964 movie; (OM) for the 1971 version; and, (IAL 2007) for the latest version.

As always, the “three strikes and you’re out rule” applies.  At the third typographical, spelling, grammar, or punctuation error, I stop reading and evaluate only what I’ve read.  In other words, proofread your prose.

Bring any questions or concerns to class on Tuesday, February 28.